Regular price: $19.60
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $19.60
This story of the Empress of Ireland is captivating for content, but poorly presented here. The narrator, reading this like headline news, makes this almost impossible to listen to. The story of the wreck is very interesting, but the writer seemed unable to tell the story without exaggeration or hyperbole.
As a diver, I understand the dangers in technical diving and the lure of dangerous wrecks. Wreck divers are highly trained and dedicated to safety. The story of many of these divers is just the opposite. Poorly trained, ignoring basic safety rules, there is a reason many of these die or get hurt in exploring the Empress. The Empress of Ireland has caused numerous deaths both in the sinking and through the mistakes of divers since. However, the author tries to make a dive to 140 feet seem like it is climbing Mount Everest. There are many times in listening to this book I had to remind myself that these divers were not free diving the Titanic but rather a relatively shallow wreck. In fact sport divers routinely make dives to these depths. What makes the Empress so dangerous is the extreme cold, the currents and limited visibility. The real story is the tragedy of ill equipped divers putting themselves in situations they for which they were unprepared. Yes they die, due in large part to their own stupidity.
Attempting to build these people into heroes sets a bad example to anyone who is thinking of joining a very rewarding sport.
There are many tales written by divers that do not resort to aggrandizing stupidity. Unfortunately, this is not one of them.
25 of 28 people found this review helpful
This is an interesting story and probably worth listening to. This reminds me of the reason I usually do NOT listen to abridged books. It is difficult to tell if the author presented the material in a choppy manner or if it was improperly chopped up by the abridgement,causing a lack of continuity. I have listened to the narrator before and he is good. However his style was wrong for this book. If you have not already listened to them then listen to Dragon Sea (good) or Shadow divers(excellent). Save this one for last or better yet find it unabridged or get the book and read it.
5 of 5 people found this review helpful