Regular price: $20.99
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $20.99
This is an interesting though somewhat depressing story, though it tries to end on a hopeful note. The main character is very compelling, and easy to care for. But the scenario is strangely bleak and the situations she finds herself in are painful to experience. It is a survival story, a story of perserverance despite miserable, hopeless situation, and a strange comment on human nature in some ways.
It is odd to class this as a kid story. I think older teens might be appropriate but I don't know if I would say it is right for anyone 13 or under. It deals with some troubling stuff - attempted rape of a young teen, a murder attempt on the same teen by an older man, etc. Not to say that kids can't take it, but it just seems a bit mature in some of its material for children, in my opinion, so parents are warned and may want to listen first.
THe main character feels very real and human and well developed and it is easy to care about her. That said, the other main character, the man who comes into her valley is a bit dispicable and frustrating and her reaction to him is at times frustrating. She has more patience and goodness and strength in her than many would, I think, though it is hard to say as we don't live in a post apocolyptic world where almost no people are left.
Overall, it was a sad but interesting story, and her plight was engaging and she was very likable so easy to follow... But as I said, the material is too mature for kids I think, some of the relationship is odd and frustrating and hard to understand and despite its hopeful note at the end, overall it is a bleak and sad story... Still it was entertaining and I think worth a listen.
4 of 4 people found this review helpful
After seeing the movie recently (much changed from the book), I thought I'd reread a book I had loved as teenager. I'm not sure why I loved it then. Didn't I think it strange that a 15-yr-old was thinking about marrying Mr. Loomis (she never calls him by his first name), a 30-something MAN she didn't even know? Wasn't I freaked out by his actions (including trying to rape her)? Didn't I find her actions somewhat ridiculous? Apparently I didn't.
Maybe some books one should not revisit.
As for the audio narrator, initially she sounded like a 60-yr-old to me. I got used to her and she began to seem a little younger sounding but I didn't like her voice or performance.
3 of 4 people found this review helpful