Regular price: $17.49
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $17.49
I rarely review a book, but wanted to comment on this one, especially in light of the reaction of the other reviewers to the ice and the rat. I found the retelling of the Titanic's tragedy compelling, which is high praise when the material is so familiar, and the performance was stellar.
First, this is not a history book, but poetry. If you come to it expecting a straight history, you will be disappointed. I liked the ice and loved the rat. As I was listening, the commentary of the ice reminded me of the chorus in a Greek drama. As for the rat, have you ever before given a moment's thought to the rats that also went down with the ship? I don't know which of the cast read the rat, but it was perfect, vividly portraying a real rat, scuttling about in the dark. I also thought that the handling of the post office, which another listener found repetitive, had the same effect. The reading of the simple, repeated words brought the mailroom and it's work vividly to life. I also enjoyed the clever promenade sections, sometimes backing up to listen to them again, and was impressed with how they were woven back into the narrative at the end.
The language of the book was evocative in a way that a straightforward narrative could never be, and gave depth and human richness to the characters, both the good and the bad. I must say, however, that as fine as the book itself was, I'm not sure I would have much liked it as a print read. This is writing not for the eye but for the ear, and the narrators in this recording deserve five stars and more for the color and life they brought to it. I had originally downloaded this free from the public library, but partway through purchased it from Audible. I knew even before the end that this was a book I wanted in my permanent library.
5 of 6 people found this review helpful
What did you like best about The Watch That Ends the Night? What did you like least?
I enjoyed the varied experiences from a wide cross section of the passengers and crew of Titanic. The rat and iceberg were a little irritating but not too offputting. Their contributions were brief enough and gave the author a chance to add a little change of pace to the story.
How would you have changed the story to make it more enjoyable?
Actually this was a unique telling of the story. The compartmentalization of the story feed everything piece by piece but it still had a timeline flow that worked.
What does the narrators bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?
They brought distinctive voices to each of the characters. Each character was given a depth of personality that helped bring the story to life
Do you think The Watch That Ends the Night needs a follow-up book? Why or why not?
No, the voyage is over
Any additional comments?
This was a bit unusual but not bad at all really. The author weaves facts with fiction to make a compelling story. It was worth listening to. I would say a good read
4 of 5 people found this review helpful