Regular price: $25.90
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $25.90
I loved part 2! I felt it was more intricate and richly plotted than the first book. The love story also didn't unfold quite as easily as it did on the last one, which helped me believe in it more. But it also closed the circle with the last story and helped you understand perhaps why they did fall in love so easily. It also has a unique take on time travel which was fun.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
A slightly confusing but wonderful YA Paranormal Romance.
Prom Night in Purgatory by Amy Harmon, read by Emily Woo Zeller, published by Tantor Audio (2014) / Length: 8 hrs 18 min
This is Book #2 in the "Purgatory" duology.
**This review contains spoilers for the previous book.**
I wasn't sure that I wanted to read this. Sometimes I worry that it might be better to leave things the way they ended previously. But in the end I couldn't resist. My first time through, I wasn’t able to keep it entirely straight. But I enjoyed it enough to listen a second time. The issue is flashbacks, paranormal “dreams,” and time twisting.
However, and despite their issues in this book, the central romance remains a favorite.
Maggie: Poor girl, she thought all her wishes had been granted; but life isn't usually that easy. She continued to fight for what she wanted though. When she told him that she missed the way things were between them, it really touched me.
Johnny: I really wanted to shout that he had suffered enough. And it was difficult to see him struggle to understand what had happened, and yet in a way it was harder to read about him the way he used to be.
Maggie & Johhny: When things are good between them, they're the best.
I still love Gus, and Maggie's grandma Lizzie is a wonderful addition. Although it is sad to meet people in the past who are already dead in present time.
We get the interesting experience of seeing the modern world through the eyes of someone from the past (although I wish there was more of this) and also seeing the past through someone from the future.
As I said, it is very convoluted. We do finally get our conclusive ending this time though. Some good changes happen, and some not so good changes can't be undone.
HIGHLIGHTS / CAUTIONS:
--Prom night, especially the parts at the reservoir
--The reason Johnny's favorite color is pink. *smirk*
--Maggie's reasons for waiting
I COULD HAVE DONE WITHOUT: The scene in which a nurse removes Johnny's catheter. / Mild swearing / Johnny's lax attitude towards stealing
OTHER CAUTIONS(?): Johnny romances a teacher (in the past) to try and get out of an assignment / A story is told about someone who interrupts a sexual assault. / Another woman experiences an incident of verbal & physical abuse
Character voices differentiated = Yes, I especially like Lizzie's / Opposite sex voices acceptable = Yes / Accents = Still no real sense that they are all in Texas / Phrasing, Pacing & Pronunciation = Good / Emoting = Good / Speed = listened on 1.25, my usual
I cried my heart out when I first read this and did it again when I listened to it all this time later. This is such a masterful manipulation of time and space with a love story doomed just like Romeo and Juliet.
The narration was great.
Read it, listen to it or do both, but don't miss this concluding chapter of the love affair that started in Slow Dance in Purgatory.
Really enjoyed the book. I couldn't stop listening as the mysteries kept me intrigued and I just wanted to find out what was happening to Johnny and Maggie. It was a wild ride and totally not what I expected as, unlike the simple plot of book 1, this book had plot twists after plot twists, while also providing answers to questions left open by the first book of the series. I highly recommend this book.