Regular price: $15.48
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $15.48
What the hell? Why would you go after Kathy Bates? You've revealed yourself to be an entertainer, not an expert. You've used sleight of hand to get me to buy this book, but I don't have to finish it.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
Is there anything you would change about this book?
No. In its own right, this book is incredible. If it weren't a near-exact clone of Alcohol Lied To Me, I wouldn't have knocked off two stars from my rating.
What was one of the most memorable moments of The Alcohol Illusion?
Craig's enthusiasm. His simple yet powerful message was delivered flawlessly.
If this book were a movie would you go see it?
Yes. I anticipate The Alcohol Illusion: The Movie.
Any additional comments?
Craig Beck's method of quitting drinking is extremely similar to Alan Carr's version of quitting smoking; see the addiction for what it really is, and let go of the willpower. It's a direct contrast to AA and religion-based recovery programs, and that's why I love it.
The main problem with The Alcohol Illusion is that it's practically the exact same book as Alcohol Lied To Me. There was nothing new in here, and most of his memorable catchphrases seemed to be directly borrowed from Alcohol Lied To Me ("an attractively packaged poison!"). Essentially, I paid twice for the same book.
A secondary, minor problem is that although subjects like 'The Kick' could be easily backed up with scientific evidence and explained in greater detail (especially the interplay of neurotransmitters being chalked up to a 'chemical reaction'), he tends to oversimplify the concepts for the wide audience that may come to find this book. However, his delivery makes up in enthusiasm where it falls short on data, and that's what makes his message brilliant.
I don't think I would have enjoyed the book, but I loved the audiobook. It's worth the second purchase.
What would have made The Alcohol Illusion better?
More reliable and valid statistics and an evidential basis to support the book's arguments. Less of an Alan Partridge "I'm a regional radio personality" vibe.
What could Craig Beck have done to make this a more enjoyable book for you?
See above. As cod-psychology goes, this ranks at Daily Mail level. Oh, and avoid the massive incongruous detours into regional radio land.
What did you like about the performance? What did you dislike?
Craig has a good reading voice and some interesting experiences to share about his drinking, but don't we all..? Who needs another D-list celebrity drunk-alogue?
What character would you cut from The Alcohol Illusion?
The author, but then that would leave a very thin book...
Any additional comments?
There's a lot of good literature on alcoholism and recovery today, and goodness knows we need it - particularly those people for whom AA isn't an answer.
This book, unfortunately, doesn't quite make the contribution required. It is one re-write short of being ready for publication in my honest opinion.
0 of 1 people found this review helpful