Regular price: $34.28
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $34.28
Any additional comments?
This is a review of the three "books" in this trilogy by J. Goldstein. What you have is a set of more then 40 lectures that take you step by step through the Satipatthana Sutta. Some focused lectures, analyze just a few words. Each lecture is 45-60 minutes long, and the audience for these lectures are students of meditation (mostly Vipassana meditation I think), some taking 7 day retreats and some 90 days. The material is at times very personal and advanced, and seems intended for students that have practiced at least 1-4 years. These lectures occurred over 3-4 years, and there is a mild amount of repetition of stories and examples in them. I did not find this repetition straining, as I listened to these lectures over a slow 4-6 month period and have revisited them. If you do not already have some experience in meditation, and practice, then much of what the lectures are about may not make sense to you. These lectures do not seem to me a place to start your study, but a place to deepen it. So if you are a beginner, put these three "book" in your wish list. Then take a class and practice for 1-4 years. A better book for beginners might be "the art of living" by W. Hart or any of the books by Pema Chodron. I am profoundly thankful the author and the group of students that made this amazing trilogy possible.
38 of 39 people found this review helpful
What did you love best about Abiding in Mindfulness, Volume 1?
The lessens are great; engaging and peaceful. I listen to them over and over.
Any additional comments?
Note: The audio starts on Sesson 6 then proceeds to Sesson 1. If you don't mind, then it doesn't matter...
11 of 11 people found this review helpful
If you have had enough of various simplistic books that tell you the world will deliver your wildest dreams or whatever you want if you just ask, and instead you want tough love, then this is a book for you. Joseph Goldstein has lots of experience and knowledge of Buddhism - an approachable, interesting, scientifically credible spiritual tradition that is 2,500 years old. Goldstein makes the Buddha's teachings fresh and accessible and provides new ways of thinking about a range of life's ups and downs. A gem of a book and a treat to listen to Joseph's wry, self-deprecating humour as he explains his encounters with ancient wisdoms.
8 of 9 people found this review helpful
Only made it to chapter 3 - more of a Buddhism/ Buddhist terminology descriptive piece
3 of 3 people found this review helpful
I have finished my first listening and was very impressed...I am sure i will return again. Thank you.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
I have tried reading the book version of this, and struggled, but I found this lecture style much more useful to get a deeper sense of the specific method of mindfulness. Joseph's voice really helps to provide mental punctuation on the really important points so you know where to start. He repeats and rephrased very important points as well.
I would recommend this for anyone who has been meditating for long enough to have some insights but also questions on how to continue to deepen the practice using the practical steps in the sutta, but rephrased in modern English.