Regular price: $6.95
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $6.95
What would have made Python Programming better?
The subject doesn't lend itself to spoken word very well, but more effort to avoid reliance on reading out long commands would be helpful in following along. <br/><br/>Listening to the narrator try to articulate long strings of digits, or multi-line commands involving structures that get fairly complex is exhausting and I found myself mentally checking out when it was most important to understand what's going on. Simple code to read can quickly become unintelligible when read aloud. <br/><br/>For example this is actually in Chapter 7:<br/><br/>a = 'Hello world'<br/>a<br/>'Hello world'<br/>b = "dog loves cats forever!"<br/>b<br/>'dog loves cats forever!'<br/>c = "f!@#@($*@(&(*@&$(@)"<br/>c<br/>'f!@#@($*@(&(*@&$(@)'<br/><br/>This was so painful to listen to it clearly wasn't intended to be read aloud. There are so many times the narrator is just reading out blocks of text like this, along with syntax errors, and has to articulate "First line, command line, (code), new line, command line (code), next line....." all the way along it's impossible to follow.
Has Python Programming turned you off from other books in this genre?
Yes. I'm not sure the subject lends itself to this medium. I'm currently listening to another title that was released just a few days ago in the hopes that it's more suitable, but so far it's looking like a dud as well.
Would you be willing to try another one of Kirk Hanley’s performances?
Yes, the narration was alright. He was clear and articulate and read the material as well as could be done.
What reaction did this book spark in you? Anger, sadness, disappointment?
Disappointment, I had hoped this would be a quick and clear cut way to cover my bases and get back into Python (I'm familiar, but have been out of the game a long while). Sadly, even after listening to the entire book and then listening again (and again, and again) to try to follow along certain sections were just too mentally taxing to follow along.
Any additional comments?
If you're using the ebook as a companion this is probably a worthwhile purchase, alone it's best to skip it and take in a video based series of lectures or something.
6 of 6 people found this review helpful
This ninety minute audiobook is purportedly a primer for programming Python, but instead it's twenty minutes of mildly informative narration scattered through more than an hour of programming examples read character by character.
Let me bring that forward in case it was missed: THE NARRATOR READS EVERY PUNCTUATION MARK AND EVERY BLOCK OF CODE.
Yes, this is programming. Of course operators and indents matter. He still enunciates every single character aloud, like an elderly grandmother reading you a URL for her favorite GeoCities Pug Puppy fansite over the phone. No adaptation was made for an audible medium, and the original book is mediocre at best.
There are no PDFs with practice examples, no website to explore further, and the audio contains as much content as a four page Python FAQ, except to access it you need to wade through babbled examples and exercises.
It's about as useful as an audiobook version of a comic strip. "In the next panel, Calvin is facing toward the left and grimacing. Hobbes is behind him and appears puzzled. Calvin says..."
Would you like to see for yourself? Here's a transcribed example: "First line, print, double quote, input your first number, colon, double quote. Next line, print, double quote, double quote. Next line, A equals raw underscore input open parenthesis close parenthesis. Next line, print, double quote, double quote."
Imagine that read carefully like Ben Stein emoting his grocery list.
Some final notes: This book suffered from two flaws, one being that the content is extraordinarily slim and the second being the idiotic narrative. The paper version will sidestep narration but will still suffer from utter paucity of useful information. As I said, the actual material would fill four pages. Maybe five if you included a table or chart. Considering that the price of the paper book is three times the cost of audio without adding material, and considering that the price also puts it against competitors who are actually competent, I'd suggest skipping this and seeking better resources.
There were some benefits. When listening at triple speed the narrator sounds brilliant. And when played aloud at work, the laughter was intense enough to make us dribble coffee.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful