Regular price: $34.99
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $34.99
I’ve fallen in love with this series. And for a while I couldn’t figure out why. Was it the story? The story is decent but the motions are predictable to someone who knows the flow of novels such as these. Is it the magic? While interesting the magic is mostly soft and is based on feelings, and needs of the character. Was it the Characters? Most of them are archetypical: The young ruler hoping to prove oneself, the wise and world weary mage, and the kind hearted protagonist.
Then it hit me. The thing that made me fall in love with the series is its sincerity. Everyone is acting completely rational and towards what they think is best, either for themselves or others. And that often leads to the tragedies the characters suffer through. In fantasy it is often that good natured characters do so simply because they were written in one shade of ink. They do because they are. But the main character acts the way he does almost out of misplaced guilt and honest thanks for all those around him. Which is what leads to the heart reaching points when that faith and trust is abused and life continues to beat him when he is down. I listened to the 2 books out because I as the reader, know that the protagonist deserves better and I want the best for him. I could care less if the army of darkness takes over the whole world, all I want in that universe is for the protagonist to be treated the way I know he deserves to be.
Tim Geared Reynolds is one of my favorite narrators on the site (I recommend his performances in Dawn of Wonder, and the Riyria books).
30 of 33 people found this review helpful
First the good. I like the world and the color added to it. Although rather small overall, there were a few nice moments... but...
This was a hard listen. It is a bridge book where so little happens that in another book would be covered in a couple chapters.
There were times I honestly wondered if Craig is getting paid by the word. Almost every detail is repeated so many times. Since most everything isn't actual plot advances, it gets crazy dull fast.
All the characters loose IQ in this book, not that book 1 gifted them with great intelligence, but the story was a good setup with room to grow.
Quite frankly, I feel confident that you will be able to move straight to book 3 when released and miss nothing important that won't be repeated twelve times in the first couple chapters of book 3.
I've liked all of Alanson's other books and provided solid reviews. and this is a rare bad review from me. The only two things that happen of any real plot are greatly telegraphed and obvious from book 1. These plot advances should have happened in book 1 then ended for a sequel.
I'm hoping for reparations to his fans by a solid book 3.
22 of 24 people found this review helpful
Felt like this was unnecessary filler just so he could have a trilogy of books.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
While I did enjoy the story, I can’t help feeling I wanted things to move a little faster.
loved it. Ok Craig how many are in the series and how long do we need to wait for the next one?
2 of 2 people found this review helpful
The story telling in this series is much weaker than the Expeditionary Force series. It feels like it’s written for younger readers, but I would say that discerning younger readers would question the plot and character development as much as anyone else.