Regular price: $24.95
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $24.95
Would you try another book from Robert G. Williscroft and/or Trenton Bennett?
Highly unlikely. Disappointing in every way.
Has The Starchild Compact turned you off from other books in this genre?
Hardcore sci-fi? No. Misogynistic, leering, odd toned stories? Yes.
Who would you have cast as narrator instead of Trenton Bennett?
Stephan Rudnicki, if he would have taken on the job.
What reaction did this book spark in you? Anger, sadness, disappointment?
Disappointment. The first episode in this series was oddly compelling and held my interest. This sequel was overtly, and obsessively, focussed on what the women were wearing, what their breasts looked like, etc. etc. Seriously?
Any additional comments?
I was provided a copy of this offering in exchange for a free and independent review. I almost regret I did. I am not sure where the author wanted to take this story arc, but the almost comical references to the clothing the women chose to wear, ( and, for that matter, all the characters chose to wear ) was silly, repetitive and distracting. This author can do better, and should.
The narrator was dry, and not particularly compelling.
All in all, I can't recommend this in any aspect. Oops!
0 of 1 people found this review helpful
I was given this free review copy audiobook at my request and have voluntarily left this review.
I thought that Williscroft couldn't get any better and then I listened to this. The Starchild Compact was amazing! It was enticing and detailed and it was everything science fiction should be! What was amazing about Williscroft was that he explored other aspects that are often forgotten about by other writers - the behind the scenes people, the aspect of religion in science and space and the book felt like an exploration in itself. This was just amazing.
Any additional comments?
A very long listen, at almost fifteen hours, this would have been better divided into two books: the journey to, arrival at and exploration of Iapetus in the first book, terminating at the point where the crew is transported to an unknown destination in the clear sided pod crafts, and the subsequent third or so of the book, possibly with a further 'return' as an H.G.Wells glimpse into the future added.to round it off. It would certainly have made the starring award much simpler.
The first 'book' as detailed above, if a little juvenile boys' wet dream in it's approach to the female astronauts aboard the craft sent to determine the nature of Iatecus, is still fascinating in the facts given. There are excitements aplenty, too, as long as the reader isn't looking for fast action battles. The second part, however, is mostly jingoistic rubbish, with good guys squaring up to save the world, at the same time denegrating an entire religious movement and it's millions of adherents worldwide. Such a pity. I salute the narrator for being able to read to the end of this inflammatory rubbish without bursting into sobs or hysterical laughter. Instead, Trenton Bennett continued his steady narration without undue verbal excitement, actually breathing life into the otherwise rather two dimensional characters portrayed. Had I been reading, rather than listening, to this book, I doubt if I would have managed to reach the end. It was only the narration which kept me going.
I received my copy of The Starships Compact, as a gift from the rights holder, via Audiobook Boom. My thanks for that. I did enjoy, with small reservations, the initial part, itself alone longer than many other books, but this enjoyment was complete!y nullified by the later writing. Because of that, this is definitely not a book I could recommend.