Regular price: $24.51
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $24.51
Not the best story, but kept my attention and the narration is completely worth it.
Would you listen to The Secrets of the Drearcliff Grange School again? Why?
No - though I've thoroughly enjoyed I would likely not need to listen again.
What did you like best about this story?
LOVE the narrator's voice and compelling characterizations! Pure magic, as intended for the story.
Which character – as performed by Joan Walker – was your favorite?
I did not single one out. Outstanding distinctions between a multitude of characters. You know the character speaking based on inflection and nuances.
Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?
No - I really enjoyed it but no extreme reaction.
Any additional comments?
Ok, the story is so amazingly detailed it takes keen attention to follow the various characters and their interactions. I see that as a positive, as opposed to some Dickensonian drudgery.
I especially liked the talents of various unusuals. Instead of clubbing the reader over the head with obvious distinctions, talents and peculiarities are malleable and diffuse. Clever structuring for the story which encourages the imagination to wander.
I enjoyed this immensely and don't care that technically it's meant to be YA. Amy's alienation at joining a new school late and the casual tortures - physical and psychogical - that girls inflict on each other as she tries to fit in is convincing. She soon discovers that she, like some of the other pupils, is an "unusual" with odd powers that she must explore and master. In this universe unusual powers are acknowledged and, in a few cases, celebrated but there are dark plots afoot.
I do appreciate the gung ho adventurous spirit of the girls of Drearcliff and their distinctly odd teachers. The girls do not hesitate in setting off to rescue a friend held captive by masked criminals, or stop another girl having her face cut off, or launch violent physical attacks on any other rotters including dastardly prefects.
It's not quite as jam-packed full of cultural references as Kim Newman's other books but there's enough to enjoy spotting. Not exactly sure what age it's aimed at but I would have LOVED this book from about 11 onwards.
Joan Walker gets the tone of a 1920s boarding school story just right and sounds as if she's enjoying herself too.
All in all it's tremendous, exciting fun.
9 of 9 people found this review helpful
I couldn't finish this book. The narrator was so irritating with her awful accents, intonations and speeds, I found it impossible. Half way through I still struggled with the flatness of the characters. The story ambles on, but seems to be pointless and very much overshadowed by the weak characters and dire narration. Nit for me, thanks.
3 of 4 people found this review helpful