Regular price: $9.95
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $9.95
Any additional comments?
This is a poem about life and a love letter in book form. If you're looking for plot and action, skip this book. If youre looking for some amazing writing and thought provoking analogies this will fit it nicely after the ghost brigades.
13 of 13 people found this review helpful
I really liked Old Mans War and most of the rest of the series, but this had no story, no action, and the only Sci Fi was second hand. This is a short story length diary entry monologue by Jane about life, love, killing and death. Maybe (just maybe) if I had just finished Old Mans War yesterday, I might have found the references to that story compelling. I doubt it. It takes really good prose to support a format like this. Proust yes, Scalzi not yet. This is not at all bad, but the writing is just not up to this otherwise boring format. I can’t think of anyone I would recommend this to. If you just finished The Old Mans War and really would like to know Jane’s deep internal longings, well. I would read Old Mans War again, but maybe some people would enjoy The Sagan Diary.
9 of 9 people found this review helpful
I love Scalzi and his world. It's generally action filled, humorous and insightful. This was more a tale of someone saying 'I'm different ... I can love' but it was hard to connect with either the character or world.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
At first I thought it was just the monotonous narration, but soon realised there was actually no point in the retelling of personal experiences. Not only were they unwarranted (readers have already attached these feeling to the character in the first book), but the reading behind why she is providing this narration makes no sense.