Regular price: $41.99
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $41.99
This is not a book which would have demanded my complete devotion had it been the first in the Gentleman Bastard series. [You should not even consider jumping into the series with this book!] The verbal pyrotechnics are as delightful as ever; characters grow in fascinating and satisfying ways, and the whole thing makes perfect sense and amuses throughout. But there is definitely a sense that, after a harrowing ordeal, we are traveling through a transitional adventure in preparation for an exquisite confrontation which is yet to come. The plotting and execution by our beloved ne'er-do-wells is decidedly thin and even uninspired, definitely falling short of the grand and intricate designs to which Lynch has accustomed us. There is very little at stake and one could easily sum up the essential action of the book in a couple of brief paragraphs. As a result I was somewhat disappointed after having salivated a messy little puddle on my desk in anticipation of the new adventure.
Until I reached the afterword. Scott Lynch knows how to twist a plot and, in the process, our guts. Republic of Thieves takes care of a lot of necessary business, embedding it in a great deal of wonderful verbal and operational repartee. It gives us Sabatha in marvelous detail and complication. And then it leaves us with a gasp and a shudder which promises an end to trivialities and easy triumphs. I'm drooling again.
Oh, and Michael Page is superb as usual.
35 of 37 people found this review helpful
After the first book in the series I was looking forward to second and third books of the series, hoping for more of what made "Lies of Locke Lamora" so enjoyable - great, enterprising characters, sudden plot twists and schemes within schemes.
Unfortunately second and third books left me increasingly more and more dissatisfied. The plots grew less ... focused ... and characters less likable with every passage.
Oh sure, there were occasional clever twists and surprises. But that doesn't seem to have helped with the overall impression.
7 of 7 people found this review helpful