Regular price: $20.14
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $20.14
Is there anything you would change about this book?
I don't think it works very well as a novel, but would work wonderfully as a speculative schematic - something along the lines of the Haynes Manual for the Death Star, but more serious, with loads of diagrams and some (optional) mathematics, and materials science that compares what's currently available with what's needed.<br/><br/>(Obviously this wouldn't work as an audiobook.)<br/><br/>But as a novel it's not so successful. We have a central idea which is simply brilliant, but what to do with it? So we get an account of the problems, solutions, setbacks and successes of building a space elevator. This is padded out with speculations that were probably radical at the time (why oh why didn't I read the paperback when I bought it back in 1980?) but are now so dated they aren't even quaint.<br/><br/>I've come to believe that space travel is ten times harder than the most pessimistic estimates, and Clarke was one of the most optimistic. Which was fair enough at the time - the Moon landings and Skylab were still fairly recent, we'd had probes send pictures back from the surface of Mars and Venus, close-up views of Jupiter (and Saturn in the near future), and a space shuttle under development.<br/><br/>But I've worked in engineering since I devoured Clarke's key works, and whenever a character announces they are ahead of schedule or under budget or that a material performs better than expected, it rings a false note for me.<br/><br/>Furthermore, Clarke tends to populate his novels with rather similar people. In Fountains, he sort of anticipates the internet troll, but doesn't consider that the technology will be available to everyone, including people who tend to favour foaming-at-the-mouth rage over friendly and intelligent jibing..
What was your reaction to the ending? (No spoilers please!)
The ending proper was surprisingly moving, considering the characters were mainly talking heads. That was followed by an epilogue which was pleasant enough, but only tenuously (or perhaps thematically) linked to the main story - which is fine as the prologue can be similarly described.
What about Mike Grady’s performance did you like?
He read clearly, and made some effort to differentiate voices.
Could you see The Fountains of Paradise being made into a movie or a TV series? Who would the stars be?
Yes - I just hope it doesn't turn into the desperate snorefest that was Childhood's End.
Any additional comments?
I'm pleased to see Charles Sheffield's take on the same idea, The Web Between The Worlds, is also available from Audible. I will be interesting to compare the two, given that they both came out the same year.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
Not a huge number of twists and turns so a little dull but an interesting idea of how the first space elevator will be built