Regular price: $23.08
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $23.08
Customer ReviewsMost Helpful
By Étaín on 03-30-14
New world, not as compelling as Wool
Would you say that listening to this book was time well-spent? Why or why not?
It's value neutral, no time lost and a little bit of a gain.
What was most disappointing about Hugh Howey’s story?
Sand doesn't stand up to Howie's first series of books (Wool, Shift, Dust). The world building and character development are lacking compared to the riveting Silo world of Wool, which was enjoyable and addictive. You cared about the characters in Wool even if the lines between good folks and bad eggs were a bit simplistic. In this book, more of the same of that but without the same general development and attention to detail. The people and the world of Sand just exist (despite all the action) and are not as compelling.
Slight spoiler as example:
The glaring treatment of Mom as Dystopian prostitute is just hammered home (no pun intended) every time the character was in the scene or beyond. Her children, near and far, do not have an interaction with a friend or stranger without their mom's (survive or perish) profession being thrown in their face as a slut-shaming joke. I mean it, every time. It's lazy, clumsy, and somewhat awkward until it becomes distractingly annoying.
While I've never found Howey to be sophisticated in his handling of adult relationships or sex in general, I thought he was better than this.
What does Karen Chilton bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?
She did a great job. Howey writes straightforwardly and without flourish (or variety) and Chilton bought the story to life and made it what I think would be a better listen than read. I did listen at 1.25 narration speed but it was not due to the narrator (it worked well at both speeds) but the writing.
Could you see Sand: Omnibus Edition being made into a movie or a TV series? Who should the stars be?
I kept thinking of Kevin Costner in Postman and Water World even though the only middle-aged man who is a 'would be' a main character is but a distant memory to the family in Sand. This not a good sign. I'd much rather see Wool as a mini-series!
Any additional comments?
I'm on the fence about the rest of series, even though the story picked up at the end with some of the most thoughtful writing and the only real moments of intrigue in the book. Like the best of Howey's characters though, I do have hope...
18 of 19 people found this review helpful
By Phyllis on 04-18-14
Ugh. Hugh, what happened?
What would have made Sand: Omnibus Edition better?
I am normally a big Hugh Howey fan, but what the hay? This was a very interesting story line (as usual) but it felt fragmented and disjointed. I really could have cared less what happened to the main characters. Although Karen Chilton is a fine actress, there were just too many mispronunciations (three when I quit counting) for me to get past. These were not terms or character portrayals, just things a director or audio editor should have caught. What a bust, the two star rankings are only because I think there was potential for both the story line and the acting, but it just didn't cut it.
What do you think your next listen will be?
Something other than scifi/fantasy.
How did the narrator detract from the book?
Mispronouncing common terms that had nothing to do with the story line or characters. She just blew it on the read and no one seemed to catch it.
What reaction did this book spark in you? Anger, sadness, disappointment?
Emptiness...why should I care what happens next?
Any additional comments?
Skip this one unless it's on the $4.95 sale rack and you can't live without knowing.
13 of 14 people found this review helpful