Regular price: $30.79
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $30.79
Would you consider the audio edition of Monstrous Regiment to be better than the print version?
I always have difficulty sorting out a horde of new characters and the various voices help do that for me.
Who was your favorite character and why?
Any time one of the Igor clan is in a Discworld book I expect to see the world in a new way; and with an Igor's help that could be literal!
What does Stephen Briggs bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?
As with all audiobooks you get an added dimension by hearing the story rather than reading it. Steven Briggs brings exquisite pacing and depth to the characters he becomes. I think he really understands what is being said, why it is important to the people in the scene and he loves (or hates) the characters as much as I do. I can see Sergeant Jackram, big as a bull and twice as loud; a John Madden-type in a different uniform.
Briggs doesn't just read the book, he gives it color - octarine to be precise.
Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?
Monstrous Regiment is satire, so generally you either love it or hate it. It picks at war, which I think Americans of our generation have not experienced in the same way that Europeans of the same age have, so each will see the book in a different light. There were hardships on all sides, we all lost people, but in the US we didn't lose our homes or our food supply on top of it all. The story is darkly humorous.
It also picks at fundamental religions of the type where people follow "the word" blindly and draws a clever little parallel to the Fourth Estate.
My favorite piece of the book, and the first place I laughed right out loud is paraphrased as follows:Having dismissed the newspaper reporter (i.e., war correspondent) who is reluctant to end the interview, Lt. Blouse, in full uniform with his sword across his knee says, "It is said that the pen is mightier than the sword", and while the reporter is acknowledging the statement the Lt. continues, "Would you care to test it?"
I could just imagine the two men sitting out there in the woods, one with his hand resting casually on his sword and the other sitting up straight gripping his pen with white knuckles, both understanding how quickly the power had shifted and how unlikely it was to tilt back.
I laughed for 2 miles!
Any additional comments?
It would be good if you could read or listen to some of the earlier books in the series, but it isn't necessary, although it does mean you have a few spoilers if you later listen to the earlier parts. This was my first Discworld Novel back in about 2007 and I have listened to almost all of the rest and this one several times over since that time.
Anybody else have a good scubbo recipe they want to share?
12 of 12 people found this review helpful
I have not read enough Pratchett yet to say that this is one of his very best, but if he wrote better romps with more whimsy steeped in wisdom and understanding I should probably not read them. My heart would simply explode with happiness. I ride the subway in Beijing with an iPod mainlining my ears. For the last week I have been subverting the common Chinese image of the American character. "Easily amused," as my Chinese wife would say, but what Pratchett does is not "easy." It is mastery. Get it. Read it.
11 of 11 people found this review helpful