Regular price: $31.49
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $31.49
Would you listen to Library at Mount Char again? Why?
I would. In fact, I've listened to it twice already. I found the story to be gripping and fresh. Listening to it the second time made me appreciate all the subtle clues that the author has left for us to discover, and gave my second listen a different feel than the first one. I also found the narrator to be suitable in her portrayal of the various characters, though I must say that she makes extensive use of vocal fry (think bedroom voice) and that might annoy some people. I was ok with it though, I found it to be charming.
What was one of the most memorable moments of Library at Mount Char?
Well I won't be giving away any spoilers here but basically the novel was one hell of a ride. The central point of the story is the 12 Librarians search for Father, an almost omnipotent, omniscient being who "adopted" them when they were young and raised them, and taught them many things. These things vary among the 12, as each has a domain that is all his/her own to learn and master.
Which character – as performed by Hillary Huber – was your favorite?
The main character, Carolyn's, of course. Her portrayal is spot on, imbuing Carolyn with the necessary emotion (or lack thereof) that the story demanded. Again, she does make use of vocal fry though so take that into account.
Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?
A word of caution to the squeamish. This is a violent and gory book. Some might say that the author made it too violent and over-the-top but I disagree. The scenes of violence are all brutal and described in minute, gory details but it never seems like it was done to excess. Aside from the violence, there are also scenes that might disturb more sensitive sensibilities like talking decapitated heads, repeated suicides, and others. For me, all this was necessary for the reader's/listener's understanding of the world and the characters that Scott Hawkins has created. The world of the Pelapi is dangerous and brutal, and it deserved to be shown as such.
Any additional comments?
If you are a fan of strange stories, stories with preternatural elements, stories with lots of mystery and a satisfying conclusion, give The Library of Mount Char a try.
19 of 21 people found this review helpful
The overall story is good but you don't really get sucked in until about the halfway mark.
Yes there are gods and some twists but it is in no way similar to American Gods.
First, the mythology of this book is entirely new not subtley based on age-old "real" mythology. That is both the strength and weakness of this book.
And maybe not a weakness; being vague about a lot of points let's the reader fill in the blanks themselves. ultimately it was a satisfying read, but again please don't compare it to American Gods. Even if you don't like it much yourself, there is a reason why there are college courses based on it and why it keeps coming back decade after decade.
Back to this book; overall it was great but I question the strategy of taking nearly the first half to really get into the meat of it. It reminds me of first year graduate students who haven't yet learned the value of being concise.
4 of 4 people found this review helpful