Regular price: $28.50
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $28.50
Any additional comments?
One important thing about this book that wasn't obvious from the summary: Although the main characters are young teenage or prepubescent girls, it's definitely not a story for children and should not be read by someone who's sensitive to the subject of child abuse or sexual abuse.
That said, while the subject matter of this story was deeply disturbing, I felt it was done tastefully (at least as much as is possible) and the author stayed away from any graphic descriptions. Most of the horror comes not from the acts themselves but from how they're seen by members of the island's society as completely normal and mundane. It was well-written with compelling, fleshed out characters. The suspense was very well done to the point that I listened to most of the book in one go. I'll definitely be on the lookout for future books from Jennie Melamed.
My only criticism on the performance is that the dialogue for most of the girls was read in a very whiny, shrill voice that distracted me from the story. Janey was the worst offender, which is unfortunate since she has quite a bit of dialogue. Thankfully the narrator's normal voice isn't like that so most of it was fine.
8 of 9 people found this review helpful
Every once in a while, I ask, “Why did the author feel the need to write THIS particular story?” I asked myself this question when I saw where the story was going. I read the author’s bio on Goodreads: “JENNIE MELAMED is a psychiatric nurse practitioner who specializes in working with traumatized children. During her doctoral work at the University of Washington, she investigated anthropological, biological, and cultural aspects of child abuse.” I think that answers the question.
SPOILERS AHEAD: So what we have is an apocalyptic event that took place maybe 50 or so years ago and some incestuous pedophile gathers some families on an island and isolates them from the “wastelands,” and creates his own religion. Other than the 10 wanderers (men) who go to the wastelands for various reasons, nobody knows a thing about what happened and what’s out there in the wasteland.
What they do know is that fathers have sex (rape) their daughters UNTIL their first period, at which point they are quickly married off to have two children. And if they have daughters, their husbands will have sex with the daughter. What they do know is men have all the power and women must submit to their husbands, get beaten up, and have to deal with hubby having sex with their own daughter.
While the subject was handled very well—nothing graphic—to CREATE a society with incest as one of the key tenants and then write an entire novel about it? It was just too much for me.
2 stars overall ONLY because the writing was so good, character’s had depth, excellent world building, etc.
19 of 24 people found this review helpful