Regular price: $33.60
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $33.60
Customer ReviewsMost Helpful
By Melissa on 02-16-10
Enjoyable story, good narration and production
This is the follow up to Ariel, a story I also enjoyed. Although the overarching storyline follows the same rough outline as Ariel, and most fantasy books for that matter, the details make the book engaging and worth reading. I had plenty of "driveway moments" with this audiobook, which I consider a good measure of my interest in a book.
The narration was done well. I liked J. D. Jackson's voice and interpretation style. It took me at least 1/4 of the book to hear a clear difference in some of the characters' voices. I don't know if that is because the differences were subtle or if they became more differentiated as Mr. Jackson read more. Either way, I appreciated the character voices later on in the book. Although I realize rhythm is important to the author and the book, there were a few parts were I felt Mr. Jackson overemphasized the rhythm to the point that it annoyed me. It was like a poor poetry reading. Luckily those sections were few and far between. Other rhythmic sections were performed more subtly and appropriately.
The production of Elegy Beach was spot on. It had none of the production problems that Ariel suffered from. I enjoyed Steven Boyett's discussion of the book that was included at the end.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful
By Kevin J. Mcalister on 02-24-10
Uggh.. I wanted it so much.
I really wanted to like this book. Got Ariel previous month and was looking forward to it. The story had a lot of promise but a two things disturbed me about the story. First continuity... referencing IPOD's and modern tech, but mostly the 'Lit' diarrhea... I love descriptive text (usually my favorite part of storytelling) but throwing in what seemed like really bad poetry really put me off. And the way the narrator read such passages made me cringe... I couldn't get the image of a parody beatnik smoking a cigarette in a San Francisco loft during those readings.
The story could have been so much more, the right elements we're there and I WANTED the story... Just don't know if I'll want it more than once.
3 of 5 people found this review helpful