Regular price: $14.91
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $14.91
The story itself is one of the true classics of the golden era of Doctor Who. Tom Baker in his pomp, Leela newly joining him on his travels and a strong story that keeps you entertained from start to finish.
The story itself, originally written by Chris Boucher, novelised by Terrance Dicks, is tightly woven and there is very little padding throughout. There are aspects that are a little better explained, such as the climax and why it worked but otherwise the story itself is intact.
Sadly, the only thing that lets the production down is Louise Jameson's performance of the voices. There are a few pronunciation issues such as with the name Taran Capel; pronounced to rhyme with apple in the audiobook but pronounced CAP-el on the show. Not a big problem but a distraction and immersion breaker. The clearest example of the poor characterisation by the performer was where the initial mineral analysis at the start of the story has Toos delivering the line, "... traces of lucanol" and Ivanov replies, "Ahhh, money in the bank". In the show, the actors put inflection into the delivery and showed they were delighted with the discovery. Louise Jameson delivers the lines as flat as a pancake. I'll be generous and say that she struggled interchanging human with the monotone robotic voices and thus lost track of the characters who were delivering the lines. Either way, it took something away from the performance.
I must admit, I'd have loved to have had Tom Baker reading this one but you can't have everything. It's well worth a listen but prepare yourself for a little disappointment.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
Would you consider the audio edition of Doctor Who and the Robots of Death to be better than the print version?
Chris Boucher is extremely good story teller he is very underrated and I wish he had written more stories. Terrance Dicks provides a workmanlike story as with his other novelisations. Wish Chris Boucher would rewrite like his follow on stories
Who was your favorite character and why?
Commander Uvanov - very likeable flawed character but not represented in the vocals of Louise
What aspect of Louise Jameson’s performance might you have changed?
Louise Jameson is undeniably an exceptionally gifted actress. You only have to watch her in Tenko to see this. But, as with other stories she has narrated - Horror of Fang Rock, something is missing. She does not transfer, like Elizabeth Sladen to narration - I am so sorry she is a very gd actress on the screen,
If you made a film of this book, what would be the tag line be?
Beware of Red Eyes
Any additional comments?
Its worth a listen