Customer Reviews
Most Helpful
4 out of 5 stars
By
Suzanna
on
07-21-13
Complex World-building Sci-Fi
This was a very interesting book, reminding me of some of Sherri Tepper's works. This book outlines a conflict between a patriarchal military culture and a water world populated by women whose technology is biologically based. The book moves slowly, but as I kept listening I was drawn into the story of how these two cultures interact.
Read More
Hide me
3 of 3 people found this review helpful
2 out of 5 stars
By
Jim "The Impatient"
on
09-05-13
Only Lesser Races produce Males
I got this cause it was a water world and because it is a prequel to Brain Plague. I did not realize it was a feminist book. Before you get all emotional on me, that is exactly what it says in most summaries of the book. There are even insects who gossip. Had I know it was a feminist book, I might have still bought it. Had I had read the reviews and know it moves slower then molasses, I would not have.
WHO RULES WITHOUT BEING RULED
This is a water world without men. They are pacifists and blame men for war and the ruin of most planets. They live in a commune, where money is worthless. If anybody wants or needs something they will just give it to them. They run around naked, but they don't have sex. They do not drink liquor. Shaving themselves seems to be there biggest joy.
SHE CLOSED HER EYES SAVORING THE SALT OF HIS TONGUE
Joan is a biology teacher in college and she does come up with an interesting world. The prose is excellent, it is good writing, word wise. The story is just not good enough to hold my attention for 18 hours. It reads kind of like a romance novel without the romance. Everybody wanted to know how everybody else feels about this that and the other thing. Some women may like this a lot. Women seem to want to know how you feel and men want to know what you think. I am not passing judgement on which is better just making an observation.
The narrator is very laid back. She reminded me of Saturday Night Live, when they spoof NPR. This mostly likely represents the mood of the book as it is written.
A good water world book with lots of crazy biology and lots more action would be Skinner, by Neal Asher.
Read More
Hide me
16 of 20 people found this review helpful