When Amish woman Courtney Willis is left widowed and expecting a baby, she moves to a larger community in hopes of finding a job and a new life. Courtney is delighted to receive a job as a nanny to an Amish widower who has three unruly children. Aaron's wife died a year ago and he soon learned it was impossible to hold down his farming responsibilities and look after three children and a household. He's overjoyed when his aunt writes to him letting him know that a suitable Amish woman is on her way. The nanny Aaron pictured was not the one who arrived. He was disturbed to see that Courtney was expecting a child. Will Courtney be able to persuade Aaron that she'll be able to do it all despite the challenge that she will soon have another child to look after? Can Aaron and Courtney find common ground and resolve their differences before the arrival of Courtney's baby? Things grow worse for Courtney with the arrival of Willa, Aaron's sister-in-law, who does all she can to discredit Courtney. When Courtney's feelings for Aaron start to develop, what will she do when she discovers that Willa is hatching a plot to capture Aaron's heart?