Regular price: $24.95
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $24.95
Struggled to finish it. I spent most of the book waiting for the Elizabeth we know and love to show up. Instead you get this submissive, whiney woman who won't stand up for herself or her family. Yes there are a few times when they argue but she never puts up much of a fight.
The ending is horrible. Darcy goes from being this loving man to an ice-cold and heartless jerk. He wasn't even this cruel to Wickham and yet he's going to treat the woman he loves this way. I finally skipped the final chapters to get to the end. Very disappointed, would not recommend.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful
"Serve and obey, a terrifying burden when one cannot also love and honor. How could she sacrifice herself thus?"
In this Pride and Prejudice variation, Col Fitzwilliam's revelation of Darcy's interference in Bingley and Jane's budding romance is interrupted by a letter from Longbourn with disastrous news. Mr. Bennet has been struck down by an apoplectic fit and lies at death's door. Darcy recognizes that Mr. Collins will cast out the Bennet family the moment Mr. Bennet passes and immediately proposes to Lizzy. His proposal is tempered with apologies for the timing and kindness in his consideration of her current condition. He offers to convey her to Longbourn and on the way Lizzy considers his offer.
Lizzy only knows that Darcy is cold and capable of cruelty to those once considered friends, she believes that he is a proud and reserved man. But she also perceives the love he has for her and the closeness and companionship he shares with Bingley and Fitzwilliam. She recognizes the advantages to her family, and that close association with Bingley may bring him back to Jane. Lizzy agrees to marry him, and Darcy is overcome with joy. But simply saying "yes" can't solve their problems. Lizzy struggles in a marriage of unequal affections, and Darcy wonders what happened to the lively and charming girl he fell in love with.
Poor Lizzy! and poor Darcy! Without Lizzy's words of refusal to dispel Darcy's pride, and Darcy's letter to clear up her misconceptions, Lizzy continues to willfully misunderstand Darcy and he remains blissfully unaware of her true feelings of disapprobation. Darcy makes blunder after blunder and repeatedly insults her family, while Lizzy rails at her lack of choice in the marriage but won't speak up for herself. Both of them are the losers in this situation. Things finally come to a head after Darcy learns that Lizzy didn't marry him for love, and their woeful failure to communicate leads to some of the most heartbreaking scenes in any P&P variation I've read.
The author made me feel Lizzy and Darcy's pain deeply, the emotional turmoil she created was incredible. I spent chapters unable to work because I was blinded by tears, and I haven't been able to begin a new book yet. This isn't a lighthearted or frothy read, but a well written novel about love grown through gratitude and two very different people coming to understand each other. Ms. Starnes' writing was impeccable, and she lifted my heart with warm loving scenes between our couple, then ripped it out of my chest with wrenching descriptions of their pain.
Who better to narrate this beautiful retelling than Stevie Zimmerman? Her voice is quickly becoming synonymous with Pride & Prejudice to me. She is able to masterfully perform the male character's voices, and her normal speaking voice is so pleasant. She has the perfect accent, tone, and voice for each character. They came alive and lived and loved through my speakers.
I received a copy of the audiobook in exchange for an honest review. I have this book on my reread list, and it is well worth an audible credit.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful
Where does Mr. Bennet's Dutiful Daughter rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?
This story is fantastic but so sad at the same time. Mr Darcy proposes to Elizabeth when he learns her father is seriously ill and not likely to survive. He protects her and her family whilst declaring himself in love with her. Elizabeth realises she doesn't know him at all and the reader hears all of her conflicting thoughts as her husband praises and insults her - often in the same sentence! Elizabeth has such a difficult time trying to figure out his character. At times he is kind and thoughtful, at other times he is nothing short of awful. As if this is not bad enough, a further misunderstanding occurs in which seems the couple are destined for misery. I felt so sorry for Elizabeth. A real highlight of the story is the stern telling off Darcy receives from Bingley.
Who was your favorite character and why?
I really liked this version of Elizabeth as she tries to be a good wife to such a difficult and complex husband. Colonel Fitzwilliam is briiliant and Mr Bingley is a real hero. This story focuses very much on Darcy and Elizabeth, particularly her inner thoughts which really adds depth to her character. The reader introduced to the reflections of Mrs Reynolds which adds more breadth to the story and was a really nice addition.
What does Stevie Zimmerman bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you had only read the book?
Stevie Zimmerman is clearly a very talented lady! Her speaking voice is lovely to listen to as it is calm and clear with expression in all the right places. All her character voices are distinct and really good. Mr Darcy's voice is slow and considered, the Colonel has a more cheery inflection and Elizabeth sounds constantly confused!! All the voices are in keeping with what we know about the characters and reflect their feelings about each of their circumstances. I felt that Ms Zimmerman really understood the story and the characters and was not simply reading the story.
Did you have an emotional reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?
This is a tale of complex emotions, lots of trouble and difficulties, disappointment and sadness... but it is amazing and really worth the emotional journey Joana Starnes takes the reader on. <br/><br/>There is some fantastic humour from Elizabeth's musings and interactions between the Colonel, Bingley and Darcy. This tale has an unusually long Epilogue told from Mrs Reynolds perspective which was just lovely.