Regular price: $19.95
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $19.95
Would you try another book from Keira Montclair and/or Paul Woodson?
Would you ever listen to anything by Keira Montclair again?
What about Paul Woodson’s performance did you like?
He did a pretty good job considering the weak plot.
What character would you cut from Lily?
Any additional comments?
I was hoping the negative reviews about Lily were wrong but I have to agree. My biggest issue with Lily was that she was whiny and still acted like a child instead of a woman grown. Kyle is likable but his weak excuses for not marrying Lily (therefore saving us the CHORE of listening to whiny Lily) and his habit of treating her like a frigging princess. The best parts were the wolves and Logan and Gwyn & their kids....Logan and Gwyn saved yet another book IMO!
Another reviewer mentioned that she felt that the author had a hard time transitioning Lily from a child to a young woman and I think she hit the nail right on the head. I'll never read this one again. Even if I re-read Loki and Torrian; i'll skip this one.
Story 2 (generous)
3 of 3 people found this review helpful
I like the overall Highland story line but the main characters in this book, Lily and Kyle were a bit weak in substance... Plot was boring and predictable. I like a book with more historical background in balance with the romance. This was my first and only Montclair book, sadly probably last as well.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
At first I was thoroughly bored with Lily and her made up problems. She just struck me as willful and careless and grossly irresponsible. Kyle behaved like an inconsistent tongue-tied bore too but then they went to Edinburgh and things improved massively from there. Ms Montclair made more of an effort to explain Lily and her idiosyncrasies, Kyle stopped denying the undeniable but for me, the thing that made the whole book worth it was the wolves. Wish that particular idiosyncrasy got played up even more. The preview of Jake sounds great though, so I'm off to get it!