Cassandra Yoder was a girl who never wanted to follow the rules. Soon after Cassandra's boyfriend finds out she's pregnant, he leaves her alone on rumspringa and returns to their Amish community. Not long after, he is killed in a shooting. Cassandra considers she has no choice but to return home. When her parents find out she's pregnant, the only solution is to send her to Aunt Maud, who will help her find a couple to adopt the baby. When Cassandra meets Reuben, a handsome Amish man, at Aunt Maud's house, she begins to change her mind about many things, including her plans for the baby. What happens to make Cassandra's new plans come crashing about her? What will Reuben think when he discovers that Cassandra has lied to him about the real reason she's staying at her aunt's? With time running out, can Cassandra find a way to keep her baby and the Amish man she's grown to love?