Regular price: $22.80
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $22.80
Excellent story and excellent reader. The reader makes the book sing or fall flat. There's a bit more angst than is needed tho
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
This is a great series and hopefully there will be more. A bit of s romantic but I thoroughly enjoyed this listen
I loved this book, so sad when it ends, will buy all in this set. Penelope freeman reads it so well, I have read books since I was 5. Now at 78 I cannot see so good, thank goodness for audio books.
Would you listen to A Nightingale Christmas Wish again? Why?
no I never read a book twice
What other book might you compare A Nightingale Christmas Wish to, and why?
I was a nurse I enjoy a good story about nursing and the nightingale story are very good I think I have read them all
Which scene did you most enjoy?
how the wards worked in the past and the staff had to work so hard and made a very good job of it
If you made a film of this book, what would be the tag line be?
the story of young girls working hard to become nurses and all the problems that come with it
Any additional comments?
a very human story
My review on Goodreads: It's hard to believe that around eighteen months ago I hadn't even heard of this wonderful series, and now I've just completed book number five with thanks to Audible... and already eagerly anticipating Book Six! Whilst it has Christmas in its title, it didn't revolve as much around the festive season as I thought it might. Nonetheless, this book picks up a few months where Nightingales on Call left off in November 1938 - Millie and Dora, two of the original Nightingale nurses-in-training have both since married and left the hospital; however we still get glimpses of Dora in this one, who we learn is pregnant. We only hear about Millie through Dora and Helen. Helen, who lost her dear Charlie in Nightingale Nurses, is the primary storyteller of this one. She has returned to theatre nursing... however her overbearing and domineering mother (who is Head of Trustees), all but forced Matron to promote Helen to Ward Sister in the Casualty Ward. She ruffles Dr McKay's feathers from the outset, and it was fairly clear to the reader where that was going.... although there was a nice little decoy with Charlie's cousin Christopher entering the mix. It was nice to have Matron feature a little more prominently in this chapter also, albeit with a fairly major health scare that runs almost throughout the entire story. I really enjoyed Effie's character, a first year nursing student/trainee. Her character is a nice mix of compassion, vivaciousness, silliness, determination and guts all rolled into one. Her main story featured her nursing Adam, a young man with more than a few issues of his own... It was a personal highlight for me to see Effie come full circle by the end of this chapter in the saga in regards to both her growing character, and her relationship with Adam. I also like how the title reflected what so many of the central characters were reflecting on and wishing for the new year; particularly Frannie, who is vehemently against the upcoming announcement of War after having lost her fiancé in World War 1. I have to admit to not seeing part of her story coming! All in all another fantastic episode in this ongoing saga. It is a very easy read, full of drama, and yet lots of laugh-out-loud and more light-hearted moments. Just like its predecessors. That said, there was arguably a bit more of a dark, harder edge to this one... possibly fore-shadowing future events??? Donna Douglas has become, from an unknown author to me, to one of my most favourite in a period of just under 12 months - she does not disappoint! I would most definitely recommend it highly to fans of historical fiction; particularly those who enjoy serial fiction and fans of the BBC's Call the Midwife.