Regular price: $28.00
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $28.00
I am a fan of Ta-Nehisi Coates. I have been reading most of what he has written since I first ran across his writing with the Reparations article in the Atlantic. I have gone back and read some of his earlier work and very much appreciated his Between the World and Me.
Eight Years in Power is not a new book of non-fiction, but a repackaging of his Atlantic essays. When I first realized this I was a bit disappointed, but I signed up for a review copy, and because I had not finished it yet, I picked up the audiobook to finish it. The introductions to each essay and the general introduction to the piece made this worth picking up even if you have read a number of the essays previously. They gave more context to both the world we are in during Obama's presidency, but also into Coates' own biography as a writer.
I am roughly the same age as Coates but we have lived very different lives. To me that makes his biographical pieces more interesting to me, although maybe not for everyone. Coates really is a fascinating author. I am not sure every essay shines. A few I think could have been a bit more tightly edited. But part of what I like about Coates is his willingness to have an extended argument. This book really is an extended argument about the ongoing role of White Supremacy in the US, not disproved by Obama as president, but exposed by Obama as president.
21 of 22 people found this review helpful
The only possible conclusion I can draw, merely five minutes in, is that Ta-Nehisi Coates does not give a single shit about this audiobook. The narrator has no understanding of the flow of Coates's prose, no measurement or care is taken to the carefully assembled sentences. The rhythm is all wrong. The narrator is trying to hard, his voice an exaggerated gravel.
Not to mention, who tf recorded this? The cuts are sloppy as hell, the punches are jarringly clear and unnatural. THE NARRATOR DOESN'T EVEN PRONOUNCE HIS NAME CORRECTLY. What in the what?? Even if he had done the minimal effort of learning how to pronounce the author's name, it is clear from the jump he has done no homework. It sounds like he's reading the works for the first time.
What a disappointment, what a lost opportunity. I've read many of these essays already, and the astounding gravity of these works deserves an equally astounding performance. Unfortunately for us, Coates seems completely unconcerned. Don't waste your money, just buy the text. Goddamn. Jesse Williams wasn't free? That dude clearly is a fan.
Ta-Nehisi, if you happen to read this... do better man. From everything I can tell this is nothing but an afterthought. A great audiobook can bring a text *alive* in a beautiful way. Especially your prose! You're not about to let your scripts get the B movie treatment, so why would you do so for your singular, precious-few works of literature? Go big or go home on the next one. Denzel should be reading your shit, not some dude who, while adequate, is clearly a budget option with the time he was given and the quality of the production.
Ughhhhh. I am just so bummed. I was incredibly hyped for this, and tbh $20 is a lot for me. This isn't a pity party I'm gonna be fine, it's just a real letdown. Here's hoping the next one finally does TNC's generational works justice. All I know is I'm sure as hell listening to a preview first.
Save your money, buy the book instead.
37 of 41 people found this review helpful