Regular price: $28.33
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $28.33
Every individual sentence in this book is understandable, and the narration is excellent.
However, no matter how closely I listened or listened a second time, none of the ideas stuck. I'm disappointed, because I was looking to learn something from this book. Even though I stuck it out to the end, I walked away empty.
3 of 3 people found this review helpful
What did you like best about Mass Flourishing? What did you like least?
The performance is excellent. The case is disjointed.
What was the most interesting aspect of this story? The least interesting?
The author occasionally provides a thought provoking idea or observations, but none that can't be gleaned from other sources.
Did Mass Flourishing inspire you to do anything?
Write this review to save others from this diatribe.
Any additional comments?
I read a lot of economic books and am fairly well versed in this area and found this book not worth the time. The first half is yet another lesson in laissez faire libertarianism. As if anyone reading this book needs another lesson on the subject. The second half of the book is a long-winded diatribe that never seems to sum anything up. Concepts are fuzzy and policy prescriptions are seemingly at odds with the author's view. For example, he proposes a hands off government approach AND NEW GSEs or direct government involvement in banking in some cases. Some things in the book appear outright intellectually dishonest, such as his claim that mutual fund managers hold CEOs hostage to meet the quarterly numbers. This simply does not happen because MF managers don't have that kind of power! In almost the same breath, the author praises hedge fund managers as efficiently allocating the country's capital! Apparently, the author lives in some sort of academic bubble, preferring to apply what he thinks is the real world to his arguments. Both of these assertions couldn't be further from the truth.He goes so far as to criticize the younger generation for being too consumed with social media, for not knowing solitude and thus not being creative and having original thoughts. As if creativity and original thought hasn't exploded on the web! I picture an old curmudgeon writing that section while yelling out the window at kids to get off his lawn and proceeding to say "in my generation...". For someone supposedly writing on "progress", his own bias against modern technology is truly astounding.My review is already too long. Just get one of the many other books on the subject instead.
3 of 4 people found this review helpful
What disappointed you about Mass Flourishing?
I can’t help feeling that this is a waste of an opportunity for an intellectual and experienced professor to make an engaging narrative contribution to the economic debate. The narrative meanders without drawing you in to understanding the point and I found myself continually checking out and having to re-listen. This is the first book I will give up on just a quarter of the way in. There are so many others that I want to read and its simply not worth the effort. Having looked through other reviews I am still at pains to extract the key message. This is a great shame as I suspect there could be something of merit to glean. I disagree with other reviewers, I didn’t find the reading performance well done either.
What will your next listen be?
Hopes and Prospects by Noam Chomsky
or Brave New World
Would you be willing to try another one of Stephen Hoye’s performances?
It would depend on how important the book was but possibly not.
You didn’t love this book--but did it have any redeeming qualities?
not far enough in to comment