Regular price: $17.49
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $17.49
I want to make it plain that while I am going to be critical of this book, it is not because I'm a believer in god who doesn't want to believe the author's arguments. I am, like the author, an atheist. So while the author and I would agree on most of his material, I simply don't think he conveyed it all that well.
The author is a mathematician. In the preface, he says that you don't need to be a mathematician to understand his book because he didn't put a single formula in it. There may be no formulae, but he uses plenty of mathematics throughout the book which is not easy to follow in an audio book. There is much talk of sets and A + B and probability, etc. During much of this, my mind just sort of tuned out, waiting for something to come along that was more easily understandable. Whereas in a print book I could have slowed down to grapple with the math, in an audio book, it's not that simple to go over the last sentence a second time.
Also, this is a short book, and he tries to cover a lot of material in a brief way. Many times I didn't think he succeeded very well. I didn't always understand what the question was, and other times I felt that I understood the question but didn't see how his argument applied to it. His habit of introducing irrelevancies in order to be amusing didn't help. Was this or that strand of thought pertinent to the argument? How? Other times I felt that a question was just given too little space. He would quote some author who wrote a 1200-page book on a topic, and just move on, leaving us to take his argument on faith, I guess.
As you can see, I gave this 3 stars. I don't feel that it was a bad book, but it wasn't a particularly good one on the topic either, particularly in the audio form. If you are interested in the book, I would recommend that you check it out of your public library.
25 of 26 people found this review helpful
Would you listen to Irreligion again? Why?
I have already listened to it twice. I enjoyed the way the author tried to make the reader understand the fact that as an Atheist / Agnostic you are almost vilified. As if morals are the exclusive right of those people who are religious.
What was one of the most memorable moments of Irreligion?
When the author talks about the fact that Atheists / Agnostics are the most under represented group in this country. I don't think people understand that you can not become President of this country if you are not a Christian. It's very difficult to choose a a political group when none of them share your views.
What about Dick Hill’s performance did you like?
Dick Hill is one of the best narrators i have heard. He makes listening to even a dry book enjoyable. I always know that a book will be at least bearable no matter how boring it is.
If you could give Irreligion a new subtitle, what would it be?
I liked the fact that the current title is tells you what is in the book. You can guess that there will be some kind of mathematical equations at some point. Don't let that scare you off. It's not that tough to understand if try and look at it with a logical mind set.
Any additional comments?
This is not a lazy day, easy breezy book. It will require you to pay attention and try to understand . That's why you get a book like this.
4 of 4 people found this review helpful