Regular price: $19.62
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $19.62
Any additional comments?
The book is well written in a very Holmes-ish style that lovers of the genre will enjoy.<br/><br/>However, the absolute best thing about this story is that at the conclusion you are left with a decision. Do you accept the analysis and conclusion that is offered or will you consider and seek an alternative? If you read closely the reality of the twist isn't as obvious as people seem to think it is. The real question presented at the beginning and end of the novel is whether you accept Dr. Watson's version of events. Dr. Watson doesn't have all the facts and ultimately makes a decision based on what he knows, given the same information will you come to the same conclusion he did? <br/><br/>Its a wonderful addition to the Sherlock Holmes genre that really explores the Holmes/Watson Relationship in deeper and greater ways! I heartily recommend.
3 of 3 people found this review helpful
The story was good at the start. When they did the twist, I did not like it.
2 of 3 people found this review helpful
Shame on you Mr Dibdin.
As a lifelong Holmes fan I'm afraid this book actually made me angry and left me feeling curiously saddened by the experience!
I endured it to the end thinking there must be some clever twist to the plot coming, and the author SURELY wasn't trying to do what he appeared to be doing.
I've listened to a variety of non-Conan-Doyle Holmes stories over the years, (through gritted teeth sometimes!) as some are definitely better than others. However, the others have at the very least, attempted to stay true to character and make them entertaining for Holmes fans to read.
After all, who's going to buy a 'new' Sherlock Holmes book other than people who wish Conan-Doyle had written twice as many?
This book takes a much loved fictional character and utterly trashes it.
Honestly in this instance I wouldn't even give it the benefit of the doubt. If you love Sherlock Holmes, you WILL hate this.
Save your money - you'll thank me.
And if you're NOT a Holmes fan, well grudgingly I suppose it's feasible you may not utterly hate it - it starts well. And Robert Glenister's narration is fine. I think that's as kind as I can be.
5 of 5 people found this review helpful
Would you try another book written by Michael Dibdin or narrated by Robert Glenister?
Would you ever listen to anything by Michael Dibdin again?
Would you listen to another book narrated by Robert Glenister?
What character would you cut from The Last Sherlock Holmes Story?
The murderous, psychopathic Holmes.
Any additional comments?
It is probably the most unlikely of the Sherlock Holmes tales. My feeling of uneasiness and disbelief grew stronger as the story developed, but hoped that there was a clever twist to it right up to the end. The beloved champion of the law is mercilessly desecrated and left me feeling almost angry. Conan Doyle must be turning in his grave...
2 of 2 people found this review helpful