Regular price: $22.67
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $22.67
I really don't like cartoonish voices. The book is well written but gets lost in the infantile interpretation of Amelia and Tom who should both be strong characters to balance Rhime. I will not buy any subsequent books with this reader.
5 of 5 people found this review helpful
I am so very disappointed with the chosen narrators for the first 3 wonderfully exciting books by talented Jeffery Deaver. His protagonist, Lincoln Rhyme is a (in his words) a gimp, a crip, a quad who has little control over any part of his body with the exception of a very sharp brain, which he uses to find criminals in NYC, with the help of former runway model, now cop, Sachs-aka Amelia-.
I read the first 3 novels in the series years ago, when they were released in book form, long before Audible was a dream. Back when Books On Tape used amateur readers to put books into tape (or even record form) for the blind. I really believe these novice readers have migrated to big time and are now reading for the production companies.
Take Jeff Harding-the narrator (and I use the word loosely ) for "The Coffin Dancer".
His voice is gruff-he could read Mickey Spallain type books (I know I spelled that incorrectly, I don't care), where the gruff cop or PI calls women dolls and babe. His voice has no essence of delicacy too it. All the men sound alike, every one has a serious New York
City slur accent, with no differences. All the women sound like they have smoked for 50 years. And when he's telling the story, between the he said/she said parts, his voice is...boring. This is an exciting story. Wheres the excitement?
With the plethora of excellent male narrators around (Luke Daniels for one and I could go on and on), WHY oh WHY do we have to listen to these poor readers.
Audible owes it to we faithful listeners to re-release the first 3 books in the story with-say-George Guidell reading them (I see he's been tapped for other books in the series.
And, we listeners need to have the second book in the series released in full length instead of the miserable 3 hour Abridged version, which is all thats available.
Don't bother buying this--go get the book at a used book store for a couple of bucks. The producers have given us a very short straw here-one we listeners don't deserve.
4 of 4 people found this review helpful