Regular price: $24.95
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $24.95
Top 100 Mysteries of All Time (Mystery Writers of America)
Customer ReviewsMost Helpful
By Kindle Customer on 12-18-14
Definitely Funny, Probably Offensive
Would you listen to The Choirboys again? Why?
I will listen to The Choirboys again; it's memorably funny and fast paced. As the novel is a series of vividly portrayed incidents involving various members of the LAPD nightwatch, it's easy to smile or wince at a particular anecdote - and then move on.
The narrator is especially good; his voice acting is incredible. He captures the different characters precisely. It's easy to distinguish the main characters from each other and fun to do so. Frankly, the narration adds so much to the book that I'd listen again to other books the narrator has performed.
What was one of the most memorable moments of The Choirboys?
It's hard to say which is the most memorable moment - there are so many intense ones. There's the time Roscoe Rules learned a lesson the hard way in "The Time My Balls Blew Up". There's Harold Bloomguard's hilarious footrace with two prostitutes who refused to surrender. Or Roscoe's macabre performance at the scene of a tragic auto accident. And there are the choir practices where some of the LAPD nightwatch share their experiences, cynicism and disillusions.
I read The Choirboys twenty years ago and I was amazed at how many scenes, expressions, quotes were still familiar to me. From the Roscoe's repeated threats to put a choke-hold on someone making them "do the chicken" (referring to their spasms) to Whaddayamean Dean's drunken questions. They were still familiar to me when I listened to the audio book. I read one to two books a week and it's rare that I have such strong recollections of so many scenes as I do with this novel.
Which scene was your favorite?
That's very difficult to say. I'll go with the scene where Roscoe Rules and his partner arrive at what might have become a fistfight between a Black man and a Hispanic man - but which is calming down and dissipating - and Roscoe manages to enrage everyone. A beat down occurs but it's Roscoe who's on the receiving end.
Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?
There was a painfully vivid moment in one officer's background while working child abuse cases. All of the officers go to the drunken choir practices to let off steam and vent their emotions as a way of dealing with issues civilians rarely experience - but some incidents are more disturbing than others.
Any additional comments?
The officers are raunchy, vulgar and politically incorrect. Their attitudes with respect to women, civilians, homosexuals, racial minorities is dated; to put it mildly. They're not bad men though; they have taken a job that most of us could not handle for even a day and they generally get it done. The personal cost, though, is brutal and destructive. If it were not for Wambaugh's masterful black comedic timing the book would be hard to finish.
6 of 6 people found this review helpful