Regular price: $16.77
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $16.77
The perforfance is fine, the location is great, there's a tragic historical context, but the new characters are stereotypes and the plot is more filler than compelling. I guess Cornwell had to get Sharpe out of his happy home and feature Copenhagen as a step in Wellington's career, but the story was a bit of a muddle.
Every so often I return to Sharpe books as a fun piece of escapism and sharp relief from my regular diet of non-fiction audiobooks. Having recently listened through the first five books in the series (not the first five written) I have been increasingly struck by how formulaic they can be. They are enjoyable in the way that a quiet night in can be but after a few in quick succession the repetition becomes hard to ignore. On that front Sharpe's Prey could almost be a case study.
Before the complaints let me touch on the positives. As pure escapism in isolation of the series Sharpe's Prey is fine. Richard Sharpe remains a likeable but roguish character and the pace of the romp never slows and the story never lags.
There is, however, the issue of Cornwell's themes that are dangerously close to cliches: the attractive woman who immediately, and somewhat inexplicably, falls in love with Sharpe; the upper class rogue villain who is betraying Sharpe and his country; the interfering officer class who can't see past Sharpe's background; the implausible centrality of Sharpe to any important historical event of the early 19th century.
I realise the last criticism is unfair, the whole point of the series is to explore key historical moments through the avatar of Sharpe but in Sharpe's Prey, and moreso in the risible Sharpe's Trafalgar, it feels like he has been shoehorned somewhere he had no place being rather than naturally following a plausible army career in India and Spain.
All in all I would Sharpe's Prey is fine as a piece of slighly silly escapist fun but I would be wary of overdosing on too much of this series in one go as the flaws in the format become more and more apparent.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful
This is still one of my favourite series. Sharpe is a fantastic character of high cunning yet simple, often rather base beliefs. The book has plenty of action and the scenes describing the British attack from within the city are excellent. The descriptions of the effect on the city were extremely vivid.Rupert Farley puts in another masterclass as narrator.
Given the subject matter there isn’t much in the way of major battle scenes, this has a bit more of a cloak and dagger theme. Of course being Sharpe this actually transforms into a cloak and seven-barrelled gun theme! Quite how you hide one of them under a cloak is of course open to question if you should choose to . . .
Accusations of the whole thing becoming a little formulaic aren’t totally unfair but this is action and escapism and it is still teaching me about aspects of our history that I wasn’t fully aware of. Five books in and I would still thoroughly recommend this old series to any military history buffs – though of course most will probably have read it already.
3 of 5 people found this review helpful