Regular price: $18.33
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $18.33
I definitely understand the comparison between this and Simenon's Maigret books, dear reader.
They are alike in many ways, except most of the Maigret's have some comic relief. There is no relief in this mystery, it is grim and close from beginning to end. The criminals are despicable, with very little to give us empathy for them. Simenon perhaps also differs here, as many of his criminals are, if not forgivable, then at least understandable. In the dark of winter, I got rather depressed listening to this and had to break and come back. I will, however, try others in the series because it was very well written and thought out. Hopefully even Cluff gets some fun at some point. May your life be not grim, and may laughter and light always find you, cousins.
3 of 3 people found this review helpful
I t took me a while to finish this book, I found it just a little boring , and had to go back a few times to re read parts of it before moving on. The reader was ok, but a little too samey with the carachters voices. Could just be me or my mood at the time of reading sorry.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful
I remembered a child watching the TV series, not so much the stories as the character striding around the town with his faithful border collie. In the mid seventies I was a constable stationed in Skipton where Gill wrote and based Cliff. It was then still very much as Gill portrays it as a A market town where the country ways met the industrial hub of Yorkshire textiles and industry. it still only had one detective sergeant aided by two D.Cs even in the seventies, they were known by all and they knew everyone of note just like Cluff.
Gills portrayal of the town and landscape around Gunnershaw took me back there able to follow his descriptions to see what existed in the fifties. The authors portrayal of the characters in the dales and their way of life is evocative of that era and had little changed since the start of the century. Cluff's personal involvement harks back to a time when local police officers really were local and took crimes and behaviour on their patch as a challenge to be resolved.
A good read from an author who has got lost in a dales backwater due to the flood of "modern" fast paced psychological thriller.
No the way of life
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
I read a lot of vintage murder mysteries but did not enjoy this one at all. It had no charm, I did empathise with any characters and the narrative felt 'over written'. Also the author appeared to be obsessed by breasts, there seemed to be a description for very female character. Very Odd!