Regular price: $20.72
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $20.72
Customer ReviewsMost Helpful
By Jeanie on 05-03-10
Another Meander with Aurora
In this installment we jump over the possible double lover dilemma that ended the first book and go straight into the aftermath of both a failed relationship and the death of a friend. It is another slow meandering stroll through Roe's life and it is mostly pleasant, witty, and humorous enough. The biggest problem with this story is that, even more so than in the first, the solution to the mystery is revealed rather than solved. The action at the end seems more than a little implausible as well. Moreover, we discover at the end that if Roe had been a little more methodical and a little less clever in the beginning, there would have been no mystery for her to solve--or attempt to solve, rather.
The narrator does a generally good job, but she does not use a Southern accent and her nasally voice doesn't hint of the South.
Still, this is a mildly enjoyable pleasant stroll through Aurora Teagarden's evolving life and worth the few hours of listening.
8 of 8 people found this review helpful
By mary on 02-11-16
Worse then book one
This book wasn’t for you, but who do you think might enjoy it more?
This is not a book for those who enjoy mysteries and like topics. It is too simple and incomplete. Book one ended with Aurora having two potential beaus. Book two starts off with both of them gone out of her life. No real explanations are given. They are just written out. Aurora had an apparently strong and personal relationship with her father and six year old half brother in book one. They are dropped out by moving across the country. Aurora's strong and influential mother is married off. She is sent out of the country. Aurora's library in book one is shown to be in a strong state of being. Suddenly, without any apparent factors it is given budget cuts. She is laid off. In book one there was barely enough staff to cover the daylight hours. A staff member in book one (who was a murder suspect) is admitted to the hospital. Another who helps out and is a factor in this book, dies just prior to its start. Nothing is said about how the library with recently extended hours and now short by at least 3 employees is coping. So many factors and expectations are dropped or ignored. An example; It is implied that Aurora is depressed about so many around her getting married. She is lonely. A new beau just pops into Aurora's life. There is no build up showing how previous contact would influence this. He appears as easily as other characters disappeared. Aurora has non existent character development in light of all things and events surrounding her. She stumbles through. It is hard to comment on the ending without spoiling it. But Aurora destroys a valuable piece of evidence. That evidence would show why the apparent murders happen. It would have shown that one of the apparent victims is in fact about to perpetrate a foul crime. He is killed as a result of this. Aurora's reason for destroying it is weak and stupid. This is more so since she studies murder and crime as a hobby. She definitively should know better. Apparently having the suspects tried for a more serious crime is fine by her.
What do you think your next listen will be?
I do not know. I do know that I will not hear any more of this series. I enjoy Charlaine Harris and Therese Plummer. I am not put off by this series.
Which character – as performed by Therese Plummer – was your favorite?
I enjoyed most of them. I have no real favorites.
If you could play editor, what scene or scenes would you have cut from Bone to Pick?
I would have cut the attorney scenes except where he tells her about the will and contents. The picnic scene that Aurora uses to help her solve the mystery would have to be cut or rewritten. I would have insisted on a better character and plot development. I also would point out that supporting characters should add something to the story. Otherwise they are a waste of space.
Any additional comments?
I am not sure why this series has such a high rating. Book one and two are very weak. Only the fact that I enjoyed Charlaine Harris and Therese Plummer motivated me to give these books a try. Maybe my expectations are to high.
4 of 4 people found this review helpful