Regular price: $16.42
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $16.42
DR. WATSON CONSTANTLY TELLING HOLMES TO BE QUIET AND WHAT TO DO. NARRATOR WAS TERRIBLE, WATSONS VOICE WAS FINE BUT HOLMES SOUNDED LIKE A SQUEAKY MOUSE OR A WOMAN. SAVE YOU $$$$, PASS ON THIS ONE. VERY SLOW AND BORING.
4 of 4 people found this review helpful
Another hit out the ball park! London, a snowy December in 1888. A disastrous Ripper investigation has left 35-year-old Sherlock Holmes in a deep depression and back on cocaine. Watson receives a message of a fire at 221B and races to see about his friend. Nothing that Waston does seem to help. Sherlocks receives a request from Cherie La Victorie, an accomplish singer, to help find her son. Off Sherlock goes. He has a mission, which ignites his synapsis and curiosity.
While helping Cherie La Victorie, Mycroft tags on a job that he needs, which has a tenuous connection to finding Cherie La Victorie’s son. The unscrupulous French detective Jean Vidocq makes another appearance. The competition between the two detectives is heightened because of Vidocq’s intimate relationship with Cherie La Victorie. Through twist and turns we are lead on an exciting Sherlockian adventure. This story has many of the ingredients, child abuse, distressed female, duty to country, saving lives, obsessiveness with solving puzzles and his word, propels Sherlock’s recklessness he exhibits toward his own life.
Sherlock is constrained from obtaining information and must depend on others. Holmes’ ability to see patterns where other people can’t see and make these intuitive leaps of thought clearly is hampered by the physically handicap of being confined to a wheel chair. Lives are needlessly lost because of his immobility, and Sherlocks becomes reckless. This is a fast-paced tale of kidnap, murder and art theft.
Waiting for another Bonnie MacBird story.
Excellent story, was compelled to listen to the whole thing in a few short hours. Holmes and Watson are authentic and familiar and the atmosphere is straight out of The Strand. Any Holmes fan will be hooked. The reader is excellent, versatile and the delivery is sharp. He does sound a little like CP3O at times and should be a shoe in for that role should Anthony Daniels ever vacate it! Thoroughly recommended.
4 of 5 people found this review helpful
If this book wasn’t for you, who do you think might enjoy it more?
Someone who is not familiar with the originals or who isn't very fussy
How would you have changed the story to make it more enjoyable?
The storyline was ok
Which character – as performed by Thomas Judd – was your favourite?
What reaction did this book spark in you? Anger, sadness, disappointment?
Any additional comments?
this author makes a fair effort but fails to appreciate the wit of the original. the Watson character has far too much whimsy, constantly padding out the story with descriptions of room clothes etc. And Holmes hardly gets a look in. I will be returning this one.
2 of 3 people found this review helpful