Regular price: $15.98
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $15.98
I have every Agatha Raisin audiobook that is narrated by Penelope Keith, and have greatly enjoyed the escapism and beautiful narration.
This book is just a mess. The once beautiful character interaction has become sour, and some personalities have completely changed. Agatha is lacklustre.
There are also so many editing errors. One example: after a conversation between Charles and Agatha regarding her having bought a car without Sat Nav, a little further on in the book Agatha is being directed by her Sat Nav. This is one of so many discrepancies. Also the main character Mrs Bloxby’s first name has changed from Margaret to Sarah!
The narrative wanders off on irrelevancies that seem to have no point, or make any sense.
I forced myself to keep reading, although I was tempted to quit so many times. Please concentrate on writing the best of Agatha Raisin without rushing - perhaps two books a year is too many. Forget the amusing but lacking TV series, and go back to the intelligent writing of Agatha Raisin’s adventures.
At the beginning of the book I wondered why Penelope Keith didn’t seem to have her heart and soul into the narration. Now I understand - imagine having to read this appalling book with gusto!
M C Beaton does it again. a thoroughly enjoyable read. A storey with good pace, twists and turns and the meticulous unearthing of the culprits. Agatha Raisen never disappoints.
12 of 12 people found this review helpful
Any additional comments?
I came to the Agatha Raisin novels via the TV series, having enjoyed that immensely, although there has been much said by others on other forums about the change in age and appearance of Agatha from book to screen...but as Agatha herself would say... " that's just television !..."
I spent the first half of 2017, on my long drives to and from work listening to the delightful Penelope Keith throughout M.C. Beaton's Agatha Raisin series to date. She kept me entertained with tales of Agatha's adventures and misadventures, the ups and downs of her love life, and her uncanny ability to 'solve' crimes, so it was with great anticipation that I pre-ordered Book 28 The Witches Tree....
Penelope Keith did not disappoint, she IS the indefatigable Agatha Raisin.
The story was not as strong as some of the earlier books, and in particular I felt the absence (or lack of presence - not sure which - will have to re-listen !) of a couple of previous key supporting characters. But it was still thoroughly enjoyable and I can't wait for the next installment. I will, no doubt enjoy a re-listen of The Witches Tree, along with the earlier Agatha Raisin tales in the coming months whilst waiting...
As one of the earlier reviewers put it - long may Agatha Raisin never age !
7 of 7 people found this review helpful