Regular price: $23.08
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $23.08
What did you like best about What Would Jefferson Do?? What did you like least?
Hartmann had many interesting, thoughtful insights about the revolutionary war and Thomas Jefferson in particular. He clearly has done some homework on the subject and produced a fresh take on both Jefferson and the war. If only his hatred of modern-day republicans was as three-dimensional as his take on history, it would have been a very good book. As is, it is merely "OK".One should take into consideration, however, that I am more libertarian than democrat or republican--a philosophy for which he spares a few pot shots but little other comment. I have never listened to his radio program or even heard of him before listening to this book. Perhaps he expected that you already be familiar with his work and beliefs before listening.
What about Dean Sluyter’s performance did you like?
The book was very well read. Coming from me, that's quite a compliment, given that skip many otherwise interesting audiobooks precisely because I can't stand most readers. I demand that a reader sound not just as though he is reading, but that he is reading to me.
Any additional comments?
It wasn't the book I expected. I wasn't prepared for the diatribe against corporations (some I agreed with, some not) or the abuse of conservatives. However, if you ARE conservative, it certainly does no permanent injury to listen to opposing points of view. However, if you are looking for thoughtful criticism of modern conservative or libertarian thought, you may wish to look elsewhere.
2 of 3 people found this review helpful
What disappointed you about What Would Jefferson Do??
The writer is a very poor historian. Compared corporatism to Mussolini because Mussolini used the same word, but in a very different context. Incompetently fetishizes Native American tribes (pre 1492) as utopian and peaceful democracies. Also claims England pre 1066 was a democracy.
These claims (among many others) don't pass the laugh test, but I fact checked them all. Worst history book I have ever read.
0 of 1 people found this review helpful