Customer Reviews
Most Helpful
5 out of 5 stars
By
John M
on
10-30-08
Brilliant! Only Churchill could have done this.
What a gift Winston Churchill has given his and future generations. This is an absolutely unique perspective on World War II. Not only was Churchill in the middle of all major decisions made in Great Britain during the war (and was aware of most of the pre-war decisions), he also has a keen sense of history and perspective that only a few historians possess. He also has a mastery of the English language and a sublime wit that brings this already compelling story to life.
As far as this volume (1 of 3 published, 1 to go - hopefully) it is absolutely remarkable the sheer number of opportunities there were to prevent/delay this conflict that were missed or explicitly ignored. In the beginning of this volume, Churchill declares WWII should have been named "The Unnecessary War" and it is hard to argue with his thesis. But his insight into this entire process is terrific. I highly recommend this set of books for anyone interested in the War or a remarkable view into a great leader in a trying time.
Finally, just a quick note on abridgment. It is true this is an unabridged audio book of the first of four volumes, but the four volumes are a textual abridgment of Churchill's original set of six volumes (but at least Churchill was apparently the one who did that abridgement). I have the original set of six and I am able to follow along with the audiobook. I end up reading the sections that were left out in the evenings and to me they are very interesting. Those sections left out are insightful and do add to the overall tapestry of the story.
It does not make this version any less worthwhile, though. As others have noted, the narrator sounds like Churchill (or at least like I imagine Churchill would sound like) which adds to the overall experience.
Read More
Hide me
71 of 72 people found this review helpful
4 out of 5 stars
By
Taranthis
on
01-31-08
Great
An amazing insight into the circumstances that led to the WWII. Churchill is the ultimate wordsmith and this book is beautifully read.
If you are interested in the war then this is an excellent purchase.
Read More
Hide me
30 of 30 people found this review helpful
Customer Reviews
Most Helpful
4 out of 5 stars
By
William
on
08-18-09
Extremely good listening
Excellent, just excellent, I listened to this as one might to a novel,it was so gripping. I have only downloaded this title a day or two and have finished it already. All through the reading I could hear the great man's voice. The reading was very good indeed
Read More
Hide me
9 of 9 people found this review helpful
5 out of 5 stars
By
Kirstine
on
09-16-11
Riveting history by a master story-teller
I couldn't stop listening to this first of four parts of this monumental work covering the prelude and execution of the Second World War written by the man who saw Britain through its darkest hours. He writes wonderfully well in a fluent and captivating style that gives a tremendous sense of immediacy to this historical record. Being of the generation born just after the War much of the bones of the story are well-known but not the details of just how near to disaster our country came on several occasions. Churchill's fine writing and the precarious nature of the events described make for a wonderful listen greatly enhanced by Christian Rodska's masterly narration. I've immediately started listening to the next part of this quartet of books.
Read More
Hide me
8 of 8 people found this review helpful
Customer Reviews
Most Helpful
5 out of 5 stars
By
Tony Wood
on
01-27-15
Well told story
Covers many aspects of the build up to WW2 in a gripping manner. Highly recommended.
Read More
Hide me
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
5 out of 5 stars
By
manutea
on
08-01-15
One of the greatest book - a must read
Tons of learnings, brilliantly narrated, perfectly written by Churchill and of course what a man !
Read More
Hide me