Regular price: $34.95
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $34.95
Would you try another book from The Great Courses and/or Professor Gary Hamburg?
I may pick other Great Courses but I will be more careful to see when the actual date that the lectures were taped. Bill Clinton was still president of the United States and Yeltsin was President of Russia when these lectures were taped. Professor Hamburg was given his predictions on what would happen in Russia after the fall of Communism. More than 14 years have gone by since they lecture were taped and much has happen. As a result, the last lecture was very out of date and gave no preceptive what Russia has actually become under Putin. The "release date" stated 2013 but this is obviously meaningless because it has no relation to when the lectures was actually taped.
What could The Great Courses have done to make this a more enjoyable book for you?
Discussed the date that the lectures were given.
What character would you cut from The Rise and Fall of Soviet Communism: A History of 20th-Century Russia?
Any additional comments?
It does not appear that the professor actually tried to explain why the USSR fell. He randomly picked topics to include but skipped crucial events. He did not include Poland and East Germany's efforts and final success in breaking away from the USSR and the USSR's decision not to send in troops to stop them from breaking away as a prellude to the USSR republics also seeking to break with it. He did not even discuss the USSR's defeat in Afghanistan as a factor in the eventual breakup of the USSR. Not really a good effort.
13 of 14 people found this review helpful
I really enjoyed the professor and the course. It is a very historical overview of the forces that drove acceptance of Soviet communism, an overview of its decline, and some background behind where it may be headed.
Highly recommended as an introduction to this material.
Reasons why I dropped a star. I didn't get a sense as to what the people did, who the people were, who the people became as they progressed throughout what was about a 100 year window of Russian history. I get that Communism minimizes individual contributions and thus this is not necessarily noteworthy, but I would have liked to see a more systematic analysis of how the culture of the country changed as the years progressed. Another reason is the course seemed to stop somewhere in the 1990s. Ok, great but I feel like I need to read alot more about Yeltsin and Putin to understand where Russia is today and what its prospects are. The professor I think could have accommodated more discussion about the Russian people and culture but sometimes gets sidetracked on points that were interesting but somewhat academic. Great I know and get that he is a teacher but for an intro course, I'd rather be focused on some key themes and keep the the academic / pedantic stuff to a minimum.
Loved the course. Really liked the teacher. This is highly recommended for those looking for an introduction to the rise and fall of Soviet Communism. There may be better intros out there but this worked well for me.
6 of 8 people found this review helpful
Is there a more partisan 'The Great Courses' series as this? The lecturer makes no effort to hide his admiration for the Tsarists, even going so far as to label their downfall 'a tragedy'. Meanwhile, his descriptions of Bolshevik political actions are almost always accompanied by a condescending chuckle, while any description of Bolshevik violence is condemned in the snootiest terms. Of course violence will naturally be criticized, but it's never Tsarist violence that's criticized. He even goes so far as to defend the Tsarist's benevolence, to the point where you wonder if the man is a descendent of the Romanovs.
Huge swathes of history are completely glossed over, including Germany's involvement in the delivering of Lenin to Russia, foreign involvement in the fall of the USSR, and all history between Stalin's death and Gorbachev's rise. The amalgamation of a skewed and sporadic history and the boringness with which it's delivered makes for a highly unlistenable experience, and fans of The Great Courses series can safely skip this one.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful
excellent for anyone wanting to get an overview of a vast and complex history. speaker is clearly an expert in his field..
This was a passable history, but just like most American Great Courses accounts of the history of Marxism and socialism there is an implicit pro-market ideology permeating through the narrative. Also, this was 90% about Russia, 5% about Ukraine, and 5% about just a few of the other thirteen constitutive states that made up the USSR: a bit disappointing for me, as I was wanting to hear about the Soviet experience in the Baltic and Caucasus more than just Russia. Given that the last lecture focuses on Yeltsin and the beginnings of Russian market capitalism, I would hazard a guess that these recordings are from the 1990s. Much has changed in the post-Soviet world since then, including historical perspective. It would be useful for The Great Courses to note the date of recording for their courses, and it would also be great to have a course that isn't ~20 years old on rotation.
A wonderful story extremely well told! I enjoyed all the chapters especially the professor's personal stories!