Regular price: $21.95
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $21.95
Book is great. I know Casale personally, he is not only a great historian, he is also one of the greatest storytellers one could encounter. This book really gives a better view about how Ottoman rulers saw the world and how dynamic the Ottoman State was against changes happening around them. They were aware the world was going into a great transformation, they did their best to respond to it.
My problem was with narrator's butchering of turkish words. Especially names were so horribly pronounced that at some point I thought this was done on purpose. If they had walked on the street and found one turkish person, they would not have this problem. This is a book on Ottoman history, and not one name is pronounced correctly. I am not asking for geniune turkish accent, all I am asking for is some effort for correct way of reading words. I did not realize who narrator was talking about even when he referred to names I knew by heart as an Ottoman history enthusiast.
Just one example: Narrator refers to someone called "Sefer Reis". Both e's are vocal and close to e's in the word "tell" or "end"; and you are supposed to say "r" at the end. But narrator reads first "e" as i in "is", and second "e" as a in "about", but longer. And he swallows the "r" at the end. For hours I did not realize he was saying "sefer", which is a common turkish word and means campaing or journey. I thought Sefer Reis' name was not turkish at all, and he decided to join turkish navy with his original foreign name when he was relatively old.
There are so many other examples like this, he does not bother to pronounce even much more common names somewhat decent, like "Suleiman". It transforms into a "Sulumen". It was really annoying.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful
In many ways this book reads like a textbook but it is highly readable. The news from the Middle East recently triggered me to learn more about the history of the area. Giancarlo Casale, a professor of history, proceeds chronologically, weaving together political and intellectual history of the Ottoman Empire throughout the 16th Century. He focuses on a number of high officials among them were the Grand Viziers Ibrahim Pasha, Hadim Suleiman Pasha, Rustem Pasha, the one Grand Vizier opposed to the whole Indian Ocean enterprise, and Sokolla Mehmed Pasha, probably the strongest supporter. They were aware of what advantage a strong Ottoman presence in the Indian Ocean could be to the profitable Spice trade. The Ottoman controlled the area from the Red Sea to Atjeh in Sumatra. In response to the Portuguese global claims the Ottoman declared that the Sultan was the “Caliph of all Muslims”. The Caliphate united all Muslims under the same religious authority, much as the Papacy did for Christendom. The author shows that shifting priorities and bitter personal rivalries at the Ottoman court hampered the development of a long term global policy. Slowly the conviction grew that tax income from land was preferable to the profits made from the government controlled spice trade.
Casale’s aim is to show the achievements of the “Ottoman age of exploration” not only the military and commercial but the intellectual and political ones. He does so in a convincing manner, making both sides, the Ottoman and the Portuguese, come alive in their negotiations, their self views and perception of their opponent. The book is well researched. Casale speaks Turkish, Portuguese and Italian, enabling him to consult all the relevant archives and secondary literature. James Adams narrated the book. I would have given this book a 3 1/2 , there is no halves so I rounded it up.
3 of 4 people found this review helpful