Regular price: $19.95
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $19.95
Not worth a credit or hard cash. This is a fictional story. It's not a memoir of a panther veteran. There was no Wolfgang Faust. Google this book title or the "author" and you'll get all the inglorious details. It would have been okay if it was marketed for what it is - a work of fiction. I feel ripped off.
4 of 4 people found this review helpful
What would have made The Last Panther better?
If this book never existed.
Would you ever listen to anything by Wolfgang Faust again?
Wolfgang Faust is not a real person.
Any additional comments?
In the same vein as "Tiger Tracks," "The Last Panther" is a fake story being advertised as a memoir. These two books by "Faust" are fake memoirs and are literary fraud. The fantastic, outlandish fiction tales told in these books dishonor the real veterans who experienced the horrors of tank warfare, who suffered and lost comrades during the War, diminishes their real and important stories and clouds historical fact. Shame on Amazon and Audible for not vetting and fact checking the authenticity of this "Wolfgang Faust," these two books and of Sprech Media as a whole.
Wolfgang Faust is a fake name, probably for an American/English writer who wrote this story within the last few years. There's no mention of Wolfgang Faust anywhere ON THE ENTIRE INTERNET (except for what's been released directly from Sprech Media and/or Amazon). I can't find any documentation in any form as to the existence of this person. No pictures of the man. No information on his estate or where it is located. No specific details as to when he died or the location for where he is buried.
"Faust" allegedly published "Tiger Tracks" in the late 1940s and wrote shortly thereafter "The Last Panther" and never published it due to the heavy criticism he received for "Tiger Tracks." Where is the original "Tiger Tracks" book? What's its ISBN? The "Tiger Tracks" story was "serialised in a number of magazines?" Which magazines? When? Where are they??? Critics in the Federal German Republic described the original release of "Tiger Tracks" as needlessly provocative? What critics? Where's their reviews and criticisms? The fact is that "Tiger Tracks" is a fake memoir and there was no original book.
With that out of the way, let me speak to the specifics in "The Last Panther," supposedly written but never published until recently, and is another groundbreaking memoir from a panzer crewman.
Having supposedly been "stung" by the public’s reception of "Tiger Tracks,” "Faust" wrote "The Last Panther" and never published it. One would think the author's tone would change after being hurt so, that descriptions of battles would be different, that this harsh criticism would seep through his writings in some way, that he'd try to prove the importance of this next story by writing in a slightly different style, but that isn't apparent at all in this book. The writing and the amazingly descriptive recollections are written in exactly the same manner as “Tiger Tracks.”
Unlike "Tiger Tracks," "Faust" actually has a rank (Feldwebel), reports his general location (Halbe), states his unit (the 21st Panzer Division) and give details of some of the neighboring units. They're fighting to get out of the Halbe Kessel, to get to the Twelfth Army, cross the Elbe and surrender to the Americans. The story reads like an action movie script. The story itself is okay - there are no more than two characters and, now that I think about it, I believe that "Faust" is the only person in the entire book referred to by name. If that's true, that makes the book even more bizarre. Even in "Tiger Tracks," “Faust” referred to his crew members by name. The book isn't even enjoyable if you consider this work as a fiction novel, because nothing of consequence happens. If you read this book expecting it to be a memoir (as it is advertised), even an amateur historian, you'll soon figure out that it's unbelievable and ridiculous and begin to question its authenticity (I'll go more into that later).
As an action story, the plot is a bland, repetitive trek with lots and lots of descriptive gore. There's no characters, there's no real plot (other than to escape out of the Halbe pocket), and there's no theme, unless you want to consider "war is a lot of gratuitous violence" as some sort of deep, insightful narrative theme. Here's the plot: move, fight, describe some horrific gory scene, repeat 6 or 7 times, cross Elbe, fin. Sorry for the spoiler.
The story contains a lot of gore described in detail and in the same manner over and over again - starbursts from exploding tanks, wheels and turrets flying meters into the air, decapitated and dismembered infantry, burning tank crews, people dying gruesome deaths covered in burning fuel, gurgling breath escaping from a person hanging from a noose, etc... It's all much too descriptive for a memoir. I've never read a memoir in which the author is so enthusiastic to describe gore with such detail.
Let me summarize some of the items that "Faust" writes about that bring into question the authenticity of this book:
- Tank crews did not wear hobnail boots. Hobnails on tank steel is not only very slippery (making climbing and moving a dangerous activity), but hobnails have the nasty little tendency to spark on steel. Sparks in a tank = fire = death.
- “Faust” refers to his commander as “Capo.” That nickname struck me as an oddity. I’m not fluent in German, but I can manage reading and speaking it well enough. “Kapo” was a term used within the Concentration Camps to refer to a prisoner who served as an overseer. So, when listening to this book, I figured, okay, they call their (nameless) LT the Overseer. But when I started writing this review and looked at the printed book, I noticed the nickname is spelled “Capo.” I cannot find reference to that term or its usage anywhere in the German language. I have no idea what it is supposed to stand for. In the German language, the letter “C” is a rare letter. I might be completely off on this point, but this nickname is suspicious and another point of concern with the authenticity of this book.
- The Iron Cross was not worn around the neck. The Knight's Cross (a high award) was worn around the neck. Faust says he takes the “Iron Cross” from his dead “Capo’s” neck. The differentiation between the awards would not have been confused by any German at the time, let alone by a member of the Heer.
- Faust doesn't mention any of his tank crew by name. He doesn't describe them. He doesn't talk about them in any detail whatsoever, other than describing their gruesome deaths. He doesn't describe his intimate service with them, as I would expect from any tank crewman's memoir. Life in a tank is a life in close-quarters. You would expect a fraternal relationship to develop among the crew, but that is not evident at all in this book.
- Except for one instance in which "Faust" reveals that he once drove a tank, recollections of previous battle or war experiences are completely absent. The author of every other memoir I've read recollects his past experiences in the War and the people he has served with.
- Just as in "Tiger Tracks," "Faust" somehow has the omnipotent ability to see inside the tanks around him during combat (in which he should be buttoned up within his own tank), describing in detail ricocheting rounds, painful and ghastly deaths.
- "Faust's" Panther is constantly on the verge of running out of fuel, but miraculously keeps finding more and more fuel along the way. I don't know exactly what route he took, but from historical maps of the breakout attempts, it looks like the shortest distance from the edge of the Halbe to the Elbe through the Twelfth Army is more than 120 km (almost 80 miles) - that's in a straight line.
- "Faust" describes everything with way too much technical detail. It's as if he were in on the design decisions of each and every tank he comes across, pausing in the middle of the description of some battle to talk about what chassis a Jagdpanzer is built on or how heavy a Hetzer is and pondering on how useful 3,000 or 4,000 of them would have been to the Reich. In my experience, this isn't what a German veteran would muse on. He wouldn't call an MP40 an MP40 - it'd just be, "MP." The Soviets weren't called "Reds" by the Germans. He seemed to know every aircraft that buzzed them, and could describe in detail the type of artillery bombarding them. It's all too detailed for war memoir, in my humble opinion.
- The tone of this "memoir" is not of a German veteran writing it in the 1940s. The verbiage is much too modern and contemporary. The writing does not sound like a German translation at all.
I've read similar criticisms of the authenticity of Sprech Media's other books (e.g. "D Day Through German Eyes" and "World War 2 Through German Eyes").
I think I've made my point. I don't know for 100% certain, but it seems to me that "The Last Panther" is a fake memoir and is literary fraud. Spend your credit elsewhere. If you are interested in this kind of book, but want a real memoir, I'd highly recommend both "Panzer Commander" by Hans von Luck and "Soldat" by Siegfried Knappe.
37 of 44 people found this review helpful
A gripping account of one young German tank commander's view of the chaos of the collapse of the Third Reich.It makes for tragic but compulsive listening.Aside from that it gives a great idea of the practicalities of operating a Panther and how deadly Russian armour was at the end of the war.A great listen.
Factual, horrific portrayal of the last days of Nazi Germany. Gripping storyline and details of tank combat. Violence and mass slaughter are frequently depicted, reflecting the desperate days of civilians, as well as military personnel in Germany in the last days.
What made the experience of listening to The Last Panther the most enjoyable?
The first hand account written by the soldier who survived it. The portrayal of the randomness of living or dying from moment to moment.The bravery and mindset of the author and his comrades as they faught to survive. The realism of the agony of war and the gratitude I have never experienced it.
What was one of the most memorable moments of The Last Panther?
The whole story was harrowing and dramatic whilst being non fiction: waiting in the forest for three Joseph Stalin tanks to pass by.
Which scene did you most enjoy?
The whole book start to finish.
If you made a film of this book, what would be the tag line be?
From the other side; the true story of one young German Soldiers fight to survive in the last weeks of WW2
Any additional comments?
Makes me think the West in 2016 could never cope with War like this, most of us have no idea what true war is. This book is spectacular in it's authenticity, it's depiction of the horror and randomness of living or dying from moment to moment. The courage and mindset of the author and his comrades is from another time this truly is an eye opener. And for buffs of WW2Tanks and how they perform etc. the battle encounters are brought to life. The narrator does a first class job to his style and accent match this German soldiers story very well. Started the second listening as soon as I finished the first listen, will now purchase without a doubt the other book by the same author. All these comments are of course are directed to people who have a genuine interest in World War 2 and the experiences as told from all sides. 5 Stars.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful
A non-stop furious race to escape the ‘reds’ and reach the west. A graphically detailed account with no let up. Provides an insight into what Germany was like as a starting point to evolve into the democratic nation we know today.