Regular price: $27.97
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $27.97
Is there anything you would change about this book?
It would be reedited, which would involve rerecording parts of the narration.
What did you like best about this story?
For those who enjoy Herodotus, Rahe presents an excellent integration of Herodotus's story with current research into the details of that story based on other accounts of history and archaeological research. Rahe's account is fascinating, if perhaps mis-titled since it struck me that rather than really focusing on a thesis about Sparta's strategy, he was really giving worthy study of Herodotus.
Would you be willing to try another one of Bronson Pinchot’s performances?
Maybe. The real question with this one is why the final product turned out so bad. At times Pinchot's reading is great. However--and it is a gigantic 'however'--about every 30-120 seconds, there is an awkward pause, followed by a phrase with Greek names (cities, people, etc.) which are then pronounced with an intonation that does not at all fit the rest of the sentence. Whether these terms are mispronounced or have been rerecorded to be properly pronounced according to someone's understanding of correct pronunciation I do not know. I can only note that some of them vary considerably from pronunciation used commonly in some academic circles (but 'correct' with ancient Greek pronunciation is a tricky topic). Regardless, the final result is jarring and often painful to listen to. It has forced me to return this book to audible despite the fact that, were it more polished, it would be joy to listen to Rahe's account at least 2-3 more times.
This much I can say with complete conviction: Whomever gave the final go ahead on releasing this version and selling it to people should be personally very, very ashamed. This goes for everyone on that chain of command, whether it be Pinchot, the producers, the audio editors, or even Rahe himself if he was asked to OK the audio before it was released.
Any additional comments?
Someone should have the sense of decency to repair this very flawed final product and present the improved version to all who purchased it at no additional cost. (Frankly, anyone who endured the full recording should be recompensed for her trouble.)
4 of 4 people found this review helpful
This is an excellent work, a scholarly but highly interesting amplification and re-telling of Herodotus informed and corrected by archeology, ethnography and the careful comparison of historical sources. But it avoids the dryness of much academic writing. The only negative is the poor performance of the narrator. His voice drones, he pauses before reading every name and his pronunciation of those names is execrable (e.g. 'ArJive' for 'ArGive').
2 of 2 people found this review helpful