Regular price: $34.94
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $34.94
What disappointed you about The Grand Design?
Narration is filled with mispronunciations
What was most disappointing about Donald Stoker’s story?
Nothing new here, dry material and dull
How could the performance have been better?
One chapter has a repeated paragraph and an omission
What character would you cut from The Grand Design?
Would you recommend this book to a friend? Why or why not?
Only if he or she really wants to get into thinking about grand strategy in the civil war
Have you listened to any of Thomas Dunn’s other performances before? How does this one compare?
Could you see The Grand Design being made into a movie or a TV series? Who should the stars be?
Any additional comments?
This book is what you would reasonably expect to come from a professorial academic who has some very firm ideas on how the Civil War was won (and lost). Basically, it appears that the South was doomed to failure by its political hubris and stupidity from the git go, a pattern of behavior epitomized by the titular head of the new nation with no practical view of the big picture - Jefferson Davis. Meanwhile, Abraham Lincoln was having some minor fumbling and bumbling at the beginning, but he was a naturally wise and intuitive guy who knew there needed to be a grand design for winning the war, and was simply delayed a few years while he found the right players to implement his vision. Well read and entertaining enough for those already well immersed in minutiae on the War, it is still ultimately a lengthy academic lecture which espouses one man's opinion, but really breaks no new ground. The particular value of this work is one of stimulating alternative opinions on the truly grand "strategic" aspects of the War. In truth, Mr. Stoker's working premise that the North developed a meaningful strategic plan to achieve victory and the South never did may not only be the obvious first answer, but the last as well.