Regular price: $55.99
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $55.99
This is a very important book for anybody who needs to know how and why the Constitution was written and our government was organized. By the way, that is everybody. Excellent scholarship, very well organized and told. Narrator was ok.
3 of 3 people found this review helpful
This is a timely piece of scholarship that provides much needed context to the drafting and ratification of the constitution. Challenging the deification of the founding fathers and uncritical visions of the constitution as an infallible text, Klarman shows that the document was shaped by self-interest and compromise rather than lofty democratic principals. Without didacticism (at least until the final remarks in the conclusion), Klarman uses historical detail and a summary of the dominant debates of the 1780s to indirectly echo Thurgood Marshall's belief in the constitution as a living document. Klarman, like Marshall, believes that context matters.
That said, the limiting fixation on self-interest amongst the states and the context of the 1780s undercuts the book. Rather than stepping back and reflecting on the decisions and compromises with hindsight to show the impact and unforeseen ramifications of the document, Klarman provides a very detailed, yet dry account of the arguments strictly from the perspective of the era. Again, context matters, and by not exploring the legacy of the document in each chapter the book relegates itself to being a useful companion for research rather than a standalone narrative.
This is a fine scholarly book, written by a renowned law professor for an academic press. It does not, however, work very well as an audiobook. The prose is stiff and plodding. The narration, while fine, cannot transform this into a pleasurable listening experience. Is it well researched and informative? Definitely. Is listening to it a joyless slog? Sadly, yes. Proceed with caution.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful