Regular price: $20.97
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $20.97
I don't know about this one? Robertson Dean is one of my favorite narrators and he honestly was one of the factors that made me consider this book. For this subject matter, however, he didn't manage to improve the book at all. In fact, his deep voice made the listening heavy due to the writing style of the author. I struggled to get to the end of the book and have dabbled with the idea of returning it, but I have mixed emotions. There were some good parts that were interesting, but the author makes it read like a statistics lecture after each story or vignette when he lists out the exact amount of tonnage sunk for each sub and each merchant ship. It's not that he gave the information, but the manner in which it was delivered was simply robotic and very annoying. This is particularly disturbing because it overshadowed the human factor which is the most important point. I think I'll give this book one more listen to see if my opinion changes, but I couldn't in good conscious, recommend the book at this point. So, unless you specifically want a book about German subs, listen to The War Below by James Scott I assure you it will not disappoint.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
Story: This book is a good exploration of the war in the Atlantic. It explores the lessons learned, stubbornly, before the adoption of British methods to include the convoy method for the merchant marine to Great Britain. As always, it is amazing when people turn down help when everything else is not working.
Production: Very good.