Regular price: $29.95
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $29.95
Where does The Best Land Under Heaven rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?
If I were to rank it with ALL audiobooks, it's not at the top of the list. It's not even at the top of the list for the four Donner Party books i've read, due to the performance. I don't know if the author's ego got in the way of making him think that he would be the BEST interpreter of his own work. I hate to break it to him, but he should have hired a professional performer for a story of this caliber. This was my fourth book about this story and I attend the Donner Party Hike in Truckee each fall. I loved the extra information that I had never heard before, but being an audio book, there were no footnotes; this led me to believe that some of the information was just supposition for dramatic effect. It was only truly telling when the author read an actual passage from a dairy or article. How would he have known some of the things that were never quoted or sourced? How would he know that the meat of the bison was lean? How would he know that the Hastings book was so useless to the party that they used it for kindling and toilet paper? On a good note, there was so much new information that this makes me curious enough to get the hard-copy of this book and check out the sources.
What was one of the most memorable moments of The Best Land Under Heaven?
The poor decision to take the Hasting's cutoff after being advised not to. The trouble that the cutoff presented to the party (especially the lost time). James Reed murdering John Snyder. The murder of the Miwok Indian guides for their flesh. And definitely, the afterward. Usually, this story ends with a happy springtime rescue. There was evidently more at hand here, and I relished the additional information never gleaned before.
What did you like about the performance? What did you dislike?
I tend to think of the performance of an elderly alcoholic grandfather telling a bedtime story, as there were cadences that ended as if there would be a spitting sound into a brass spittoon, or perhaps a wad of vomit exiting his vocal canal. Or, on the bright side, think of an old-timey gold miner spinning a yarn. It just could have been better. For the Donner story, I prefer the performance from Desperate Passage: The Donner Party's Perilous Journey West by Ethan Rarick.
If you were to make a film of this book, what would the tag line be?
The Hunger of the Trail
Any additional comments?
I wish that there was a downloadable accompanying PDF with maps and photos.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful
Really a fascinating story but the narrator is awful!! He's clearly an inexperienced reader, leading to a choppy and grating narrative. I had to return this audio book at only around 20%. I'll pick up the actual book someday and read it myself.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful