Regular price: $24.31
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $24.31
Would you try another book from Graeme Kent and/or John Telfer?
What was most disappointing about Graeme Kent’s story?
The story is supposed to be about "deserter's" through history. The book is read in a style more suited for a comedy. The book also appears to be part of a cover up. What cover up? There is not one word about the only American soldier executed for desertion Eddie Slovik, I am familiar with Mr. Slovic;s story and hoped for insights. But since the execution was done in secret it appears the story remains in the dark.
Would you be willing to try another one of John Telfer’s performances?
You didn’t love this book... but did it have any redeeming qualities?
If believable hearing of a few well known men who were deserters.
Any additional comments?
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
I recently listened to a great book about ww2 deserters. I immediately purchased this when I saw it because I so enjoyed the other book and wanted to know more.
The book begins with a very interesting discussion of desertion through recorded time. It contains many interesting anecdotes and legends. It is a pleasant listen.
However, the discussion is somewhat shallow. The author doesn't address, with any real depth, the reasons and consequences of desertion. His discussion barely scratches the surface of a this very complex and important issue.
By the time the spotlight turns to WW I and II, the author uses so many different examples that the names and details become hard to follow. I would have enjoyed fewer stories and more in-depth analysis of the soldiers' experiences, reasons for and consequences of desertion. This is an emotional topic that seems hard to really grasp unless you've been in a combat situation. I hoped to finish the book with a better understanding of the psychological and social issues soldiers face when deciding to desert.
That being said, I recognize that my expectations and subsequent opinion of this work were definitely colored by a book I had previously read on the topic. Many listeners will find this book fascinating because of the endless variety of unique and interesting stories. I can say it was never boring. Also the book was very well researched. All in all, it is very entertaining.
6 of 9 people found this review helpful