Regular price: $34.96
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $34.96
Glatthaar investigates the South's commitment to the war and its gradual erosion, and he analyzes Lee's army in triumph and defeat. Fourteen years in the making, this scholarly tour-de-force upends much of the conventional wisdom about the Civil War.
Customer ReviewsMost Helpful
By Joseph on 01-25-09
Hard to believe the stamina of this army.
While listening it was difficult not to have much empathy for the Southern soldier of the Civil War. The incredible hardships and desperate situations they faced for almost the entire war would be overwhelming to lesser men. The twist was that in the end they realized win or lose slavery was at an end, yet they fought on. It was an intersting insight into the thoughts and delimmas they faced and died for, what a waste. All-in-all it was a good book well written and eazy to listen to.
3 of 3 people found this review helpful
By Lorin Radtke on 08-08-08
Bad history, worse statistic
This book was a BIG MISS. It is a disservice to Lee and his staff's genius and mistakes. It also grossly misrepresents the metal and courage of the common soldier on both sides. If you have read anything about the civil war u will be very disappointed. It puts the confederate army on a mystical pedestal while ignoring military axioms like the impact of a flank attack, the value of good ground, west point officers vs politically appointed officers and the impact of assaulting a fortified position. It ignores the fact that the charge at Fredericksburg was no different than Picketts charge and that 2 to 1 ratio of attacker to defender wasn't enough to take the position no matter how "mythically fantastic" the soldier. The statistics in the book draw incorrect conclusions...if u have ever taken a stats class in your life you will be scratching your head at his conclusions. Don't waste your time...
7 of 8 people found this review helpful