Regular price: $24.95
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $24.95
First of all, let me say that if you make it to the end, congratulations! It is a good story about the history of downtown Memphis in the area surrounding the now touristy Beale Street. The book sheds a lot of light on why parts of the city have developed they way they have and the politics involved in the shaping of a black river town into a major metropolitan city.
Stay with me... the story IS a good one, but it took a sheer force of will to get going on this book. Having lived in and around Memphis most of my life, but having been away for the past almost 20 years, I was really looking forward to this historical glimpse into the city where I grew up. But the narration. is. painful... The narrator over-pronounces most words, pauses in bizarre places in the sentence, and even mispronounced at least 10 commonplace words (not proper names or place names, just common words) before I lost count. The first time I tried to listen, I gave up and couldn't do it. But two or three audiobooks later, I decided to give it another go. The print versions of the book have solid reviews so I knew that the story was in there somewhere.
This tale unfolds after the Civil War, beginning with Robert Church, the first black millionaire from the South and leads to a political battle for control of the city between the blacks of downtown sponsored by the Church family and fortune, and the whites of uptown, sponsored by E.H. 'The Boss' Crump and his fortune, right up to the race riots in the 60's. Having grown up in the city just after the race riots, this book was a bit of a prequel to my childhood. It was fun to hear street names and businesses that I remember from my youth.
Now... for the solution to the problem of the narrator. About an hour into my second go at trying to listen to this book, it dawned on me that I was feeling a constant urge to yell "get on with it!" So that's exactly what I did. I hit that little icon on my device that says "1.0 Speed". I opted instead for "1.5 Speed". Lo and behold, things suddenly got a lot more tolerable. I don't think any amount of tweaking could ever make it "good". But tolerable was sufficient. I finally felt I could listen to the story without cringing or having my mind wander between words. That is, until the narrator mispronounced a word. Those were like mental speed bumps that you never saw coming. My ears would hit one of those and BAM! Brain fell off the track. I'd spend several seconds trying get my head around the weird pronunciation and then have to run to catch back up to the storyline, that was clipping along at 1.5x the normal rate. About mid-story, I put the narration speed back to 1.0 and it was fine for the rest of the book. Either the narrator found his groove, or I just got used to listening to him. I'll never know because I doubt I will put myself through the pain of listening to him again.
If you find this book in print, or done by another narrator, I'd certainly recommend it. As it is with this version, have a fourth grader read you his history book. It will sound better.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?
I have this book in e-book format but prefer audio versions of books so I was thrilled when I saw this was available. This is the worst narrator I have ever heard. Words mispronounced - not cities and streets unique to this city but basic English language.
Who was your favorite character and why?
How could the performance have been better?
Different narrator. Good lord, any narrator would be an improvement. I can not believe that this narrator makes a living at this.
Any additional comments?
This version should be pulled from Audible and replaced with something completely new.
0 of 1 people found this review helpful