Regular price: $17.55
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $17.55
What did you like most about When It's a Jar?
Its a continuation of the You Space story and very Holt, especially how believable the paralel worlds are.
Would you recommend When It's a Jar to your friends? Why or why not?
Very Holt and full of believable twists but a bit complex, looses its way a little and misses the humour of other Holt work which I would recommend first.
What three words best describe Ray Sawyer’s voice?
Clear. Good characterization.
If you made a film of this book, what would be the tag line be?
Discworld meets our world.
Any additional comments?
Glad I read it and a big Holt fan.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
Sadly this book drones on and on and is not helped by the narrator's annoying voice characterisations. You could doze off halfway though and not notice the gap in the story.
The book before this, "Doughnut", was not as good as its predecessors and in this book references are made to it, previous stories and said doughnuts and their function, but I think Tom Holt could rejig his usually startling imagination.
His ironic style is still in evidence and there are some wonderful one-liners, but the story moves so very slowly, like a tired snail attempting to scale the summit of a cell-phone repeater tower when the drizzle fades leaving the gastropod stuck halfway up, the clouds are evaporating, the dehydrating summer sun is beginning to beat down and it thinks to itself (in Ray Sawyer's annoying nasal twang) "I should have listened to my gran when she said "You are no Edmund Hillary, don't do it even if it IS there!", (actually my snail is more interesting than the wretched "hero" of Tom's book!).
I first encountered Tom Holt when I bought "Of Life, Liberty And The Pursuit Of Sausages" then "The Portable Door", I found both highly entertaining, original and worth recommending. "Barking"and "In Your Dreams" were quite good too.
Unfortunately this book is neither original nor entertaining and I shall "return" it.
3 of 4 people found this review helpful